{ "record_type": "edition-specific citation and source-boundary map", "resource_id": "ARC-RN-019", "resource_version": "1.0", "review_date": "2026-10-21", "reviewer": "Codex (ARC editorial preparation)", "original_source_sha256": "5915f6ed20d655ede73981d258bb754093c96663d3a53425adbfbbc2ebfba919", "publication_source_sha256": "e3f997f40e734d4a8376b9a06f9872b3baa3a591d069034b69f41b8e6654e1de", "original_session_authenticated": false, "scope": "Full-structure selected-source reconstruction and direct constitutional/source repair; no independent review, original-session authentication or empirical consciousness adjudication.", "references": [ { "id": "NEVINS", "title": "Nevins, Halakhic Responses to Artificial Intelligence and Autonomous Machines", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf", "sha256": "07bc7de3416d483367116d44b9b1b9611e1a1710c0fd75cd2fe621bf90b15902", "bytes": 928263, "content_type": "application/pdf", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Approval and questions on p.1; agency/liability discussion and pp.29–43; English/Hebrew primary appendix p.47. Selected passages, not all 47 pages.", "original_markers": [ "turn1search0", "turn3view2", "turn3view1", "turn4view0", "turn3view0", "turn4view2", "turn4view1", "turn2view0" ] }, { "id": "NEVINS-RECORD", "title": "CJLS catalogue record", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/node/48892", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/node/48892", "sha256": "ab4c927bce0f5a2dd3625fdd488339c253fb440f5b0283af54c3439cdf5fe0e5", "bytes": 55415, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Catalogue identity, author, year and link; not independent corroboration of the responsum.", "original_markers": [ "turn1search4" ] }, { "id": "NAVON-THESIS", "title": "Navon, The Moral Status of Artificial Intelligence", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/Misc/TheMoralStatusOfAI_Thesis_MoisNavon_V5.pdf", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/Misc/TheMoralStatusOfAI_Thesis_MoisNavon_V5.pdf", "sha256": "f4201cf031df7cb30f94af78e330c6fe5a849e5351f9b407b015440dbe59598e", "bytes": 1779544, "content_type": "application/pdf", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Title/submission date, selected personhood/consciousness discussion, chapter conclusions on servitude and creation, and concluding pp.165–168; not a claim to read all 240 PDF pages.", "original_markers": [ "turn17view1", "turn18view0", "turn18view1", "turn18view2", "turn18view3" ] }, { "id": "NAVON-OXFORD", "title": "Navon, AI Personhood from the Perspective of Jewish Philosophy, accepted manuscript", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "sha256": "621ed68431d648ff7ae98378239d87c04f3fc0f15e0a629113ea59dd1bae237a", "bytes": 361318, "content_type": "application/pdf", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Accepted manuscript, argument pp.1–11 and relevant endnotes pp.21–24 including 30–55; linked to published chapter identity. Not an independent witness from the thesis.", "original_markers": [ "turn16search25", "turn11view3", "turn12view0", "turn11view2", "turn11view1", "turn12view1", "turn12view2", "turn12view3" ] }, { "id": "NAVON-OUP", "title": "Oxford published abstract and metadata", "url": "https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/59762/chapter-abstract/508604085", "error": "HTTP Error 403: Forbidden", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Published abstract/date and DOI through web text service; direct request returned 403. No publisher full-text access claimed.", "original_markers": [] }, { "id": "NAVON-LOVE-PUBLISHED", "title": "Lovebot, published article", "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00146-025-02574-6", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00146-025-02574-6?error=cookies_not_supported&code=88f74455-019a-4a47-89cb-af4f9a9dc145", "sha256": "ce04f611bdd6e322bf2252f1bcece7743a5c71483878d40f01bac99cf1f08710", "bytes": 465853, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn16search28" ] }, { "id": "HARRIS-RECORD", "title": "Alex Harris, Becoming One Like Us, publisher record", "url": "https://traditiononline.org/becoming-one-like-us-jewish-tradition-and-artificial-intelligence/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://traditiononline.org/becoming-one-like-us-jewish-tradition-and-artificial-intelligence/", "sha256": "f841e316628bb3dd25565bfdc7ed80c1244de0b8373b8fefc2392a39168ef646", "bytes": 107243, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Publisher author/title/issue/date only. Page requires login for full article; detailed article claims were not checked or inferred from metadata.", "original_markers": [ "turn10search3", "turn10search1" ] }, { "id": "TZOHAR", "title": "Tzohar, Using Artificial Intelligence Systems to Rule Halacha, abridged English paper", "url": "https://ethics.tzohar.org.il/en/using-artificial-intelligence-systems-to-rule-halacha-abridged-position-paper/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://ethics.tzohar.org.il/en/using-artificial-intelligence-systems-to-rule-halacha-abridged-position-paper/", "sha256": "51b972d6396a6eec794f0f23de8fd202bfcd70735bb19ad0acf676ab72c82f6a", "bytes": 253979, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn21view0", "turn21view1", "turn22search0", "turn22search4" ] }, { "id": "OU-OHRBIT", "title": "OU OHRBIT launch announcement", "url": "https://www.ou.org/news/the-orthodox-union-launches-revolutionary-ai-powered-torah-app/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.ou.org/news/the-orthodox-union-launches-revolutionary-ai-powered-torah-app/", "sha256": "bc069dec4690a0e5f21afc01557cfc96d8d5fee934eea63888d02266401212bd", "bytes": 87541, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn22search1" ] }, { "id": "SMUHA-NEWS", "title": "Reconstructing Judaism, What It Means to Be Human in an Algorithmized World", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/news/what-it-means-to-be-human-in-an-algorithmized-world/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/news/what-it-means-to-be-human-in-an-algorithmized-world/", "sha256": "742f0cd86354cae7f721f16b944d1e85f5ec7cabeefe16b9fc5fa2cdf94966a1", "bytes": 310334, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search1" ] }, { "id": "CCAR-AI", "title": "CCAR 5784.2 Artificial Intelligence and Authorship", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/5784-2-artificial-intelligence-and-authorship/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/5784-2-artificial-intelligence-and-authorship/", "sha256": "815e8947235de61e25980c42497154e4c47f4d708d13d3b58bd2c4e593028dcc", "bytes": 94858, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search2", "turn7view1", "turn7view2" ] }, { "id": "JTS-INTEGRITY", "title": "JTS Academic Integrity, revised Fall 2024", "url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/academic-integrity/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/academic-integrity/", "sha256": "b836294fd119d09d4f0b34be42437f858db33b2de4715f15385880d3751bf9fd", "bytes": 129851, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Academic integrity policy, revised Fall 2024, including AI and instructor guidance.", "original_markers": [] }, { "id": "JTS-2024", "title": "JTS Student Information and Academic Policies 2024–25", "url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Student-Information-and-Policies-AY-24-25.pdf", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Student-Information-and-Policies-AY-24-25.pdf", "sha256": "323f16b57a48516d5b47efea3449aa7e5826c1b2b186bb9dbf001da7e76896fb", "bytes": 592959, "content_type": "application/pdf", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "2024–25 academic policy passages on misrepresentation and instructor control of permitted tools; historical institutional policy, not a claim about every later revision.", "original_markers": [ "turn22search2" ] }, { "id": "YU-EDUCATORS", "title": "Azrieli Educator Resources", "url": "https://www.yu.edu/azrieli/educators-resources", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.yu.edu/azrieli/educators-resources", "sha256": "28fdc36b53772067c7916c00698559c20f45057bd47157f83934a3e01a747e28", "bytes": 103348, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn22search3" ] }, { "id": "MARCUS-GOLEM", "title": "Mitch Marcus, ChatGPT Is the Opposite of the Golem", "url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/chatgpt-is-the-opposite-of-the-golem/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/chatgpt-is-the-opposite-of-the-golem/", "sha256": "b6e4f6cdac2b3c847e8a78022289496cf54a7667ba1f3f4713c5bd0a4aae60ea", "bytes": 207174, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search12" ] }, { "id": "MARCUS-POWER", "title": "Mitch Marcus, The Power and Danger of Artificial Intelligence", "url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/the-power-and-danger-of-artificial-intelligence/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/the-power-and-danger-of-artificial-intelligence/", "sha256": "5345ceebbff42f8e598e6afb542e11d7ab2b1e7492500b8264694d768f198de9", "bytes": 288647, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search4" ] }, { "id": "EVOLVE-TECH", "title": "Evolve technology collection", "url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/category/technology/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/category/technology/", "sha256": "c6b289f86b8c869dff22dcfea56accf7edf9b2bc60e92c6761e94d7814bd7f62", "bytes": 292606, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search18", "turn15search7" ] }, { "id": "NAVON-EUDEMONIA", "title": "Navon, Eudemonia of a Machine", "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-024-00553-z", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-024-00553-z?error=cookies_not_supported&code=b402d273-c688-4552-b3d3-f9801625d6d7", "sha256": "de591ca80b62ac0b0394fe62f1d1b8568f2cf7ecbc40570d04b0d9e6b6af3e89", "bytes": 456820, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn16search13" ] }, { "id": "CJLS-AUTHORITY", "title": "CJLS policy and local decisor authority", "url": "https://rabbinicalassembly.org/resources/committee-jewish-law-and-standards", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://rabbinicalassembly.org/resources/committee-jewish-law-and-standards", "sha256": "dbdf98882825bf681ce20d18dcf0ac9f553408c1aaa2322d59d270d7aa1108ba", "bytes": 71682, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn19search0", "turn19search4" ] }, { "id": "CCAR-AUTONOMY", "title": "CCAR archive, rabbinic autonomy", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/nyp-no-5761-3/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/nyp-no-5761-3/", "sha256": "2ae5d6051e0f76075b223548c8f807b842909480b23c0d8a7231d71d372d0283", "bytes": 106302, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn19search1", "turn15search8" ] }, { "id": "RECON-BEHAVING", "title": "Reconstructionism: Behaving", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/learn/reconstructionism-behaving/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/learn/reconstructionism-behaving/", "sha256": "b8ab20f437c786ea687c572a026673cf8383edcf7d85c9c51269cd83116e279a", "bytes": 282612, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search6" ] }, { "id": "RECON-VALUES", "title": "Values-Based Decision Making", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/article/values-based-decision-making/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/article/values-based-decision-making/", "sha256": "417ea7322e7db74ea0c62194174f903426021eb7172904248f5ec1fc8e926a03", "bytes": 331059, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search3" ] }, { "id": "RECON-FOUNDATIONS", "title": "Reconstructionist Revolution: Foundational Ideas", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/article/reconstructionist-revolution-foundational-ideas/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/article/reconstructionist-revolution-foundational-ideas/", "sha256": "9b253ca0fb8e699797418d4b0b00fc135f643248e1798c93093304cc85129f96", "bytes": 344238, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search11" ] }, { "id": "RCA-VAAD", "title": "RCA Vaad Halachah", "url": "https://rabbis.org/vaad-halachah/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://rabbis.org/vaad-halachah/", "sha256": "afce9cf21c98b34b1ac684786c8c0be1a7ba2aa5add4af4f2b874190d6f39e24", "bytes": 109458, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn19search2" ] }, { "id": "SMUHA-THESIS", "title": "Smuha, The Human Condition in an Algorithmized World", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/files/nsmuha_humancondition.pdf", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/files/nsmuha_humancondition.pdf", "sha256": "7f0bdb36e6ea42d53da15b150c36f1ddee1263b63808bc259f8177c6279e78c9", "bytes": 803357, "content_type": "application/pdf", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Primary philosophy thesis abstract, introduction and selected relational/algorithmic-governance arguments; publication lineage corroborated by institution prize record. Not all 73 pages read.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search10" ] }, { "id": "CCAR-JOURNAL", "title": "The Reform Jewish Quarterly Fall 2025", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/the-reform-jewish-quarterly-fall-2025/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/the-reform-jewish-quarterly-fall-2025/", "sha256": "4b9ad8dc6507e86cb2cb3717c7a7e8b38db5e404e9419e78a24928d9ee77bea7", "bytes": 95941, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Issue contents and Fall 2025 label only; individual listed essays not read or treated as denominational positions.", "original_markers": [ "turn15search5" ] }, { "id": "JTS-EVENTS", "title": "JTS, The Future of Torah, 26 October 2026 event notice", "url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/event/future-torah-jewish-learning-age-ai/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/event/future-torah-jewish-learning-age-ai/", "sha256": "2d778dcced3c57c5e3bf8ddc573bf537bbbd6059ad8fa001cfa7852a3e3079ae", "bytes": 137040, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn22search5" ] }, { "id": "GENESIS-IMAGE", "title": "Genesis 1:26–27", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Genesis.1.26-27", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Genesis.1.26-27", "sha256": "cb0ddfaee2b0444796e6bf9c71502839564667b48f0dc85ffad99cd4081cd8ba", "bytes": 134289, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Specified canonical passage in Hebrew/Aramaic and available English translation through the library public text API. Ordinary HTML route returns an application shell.", "original_markers": [ "turn23search0" ], "alternate_access": { "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/api/texts/Genesis.1.26-27?context=0&commentary=0", "sha256": "5d2999ac00286f0231139764ed6c5d441aa1976651b1e3e2133e83a2303af92b", "version_title": "THE JPS TANAKH: Gender-Sensitive Edition", "hebrew_version_title": "Miqra according to the Masorah" } }, { "id": "GENESIS-BREATH", "title": "Genesis 2:7", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Genesis.2.7", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Genesis.2.7", "sha256": "329eff63487d0b8c5d45a134117ab84eef5935f76f6518295b59cd4f48fea8f6", "bytes": 124282, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Specified canonical passage in Hebrew/Aramaic and available English translation through the library public text API. Ordinary HTML route returns an application shell.", "original_markers": [ "turn23search1" ], "alternate_access": { "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/api/texts/Genesis.2.7?context=0&commentary=0", "sha256": "8d35cf5417052dd711a0e04dabf9a16708fa07f2213833a678bf3c900600a3e8", "version_title": "THE JPS TANAKH: Gender-Sensitive Edition", "hebrew_version_title": "Miqra according to the Masorah" } }, { "id": "SANHEDRIN", "title": "Sanhedrin 65b:17", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.65b.17", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.65b.17", "sha256": "08a7a47307702f691b8063facc441e1e2353546b87d16c0bb885e4d518a16cf6", "bytes": 99897, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Specified canonical passage in Hebrew/Aramaic and available English translation through the library public text API. Ordinary HTML route returns an application shell.", "original_markers": [ "turn23search3", "turn23search7" ], "alternate_access": { "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/api/texts/Sanhedrin.65b.17?context=0&commentary=0", "sha256": "5035737b97157b0835f86b670544821eea347fc0aa7ed856224494764eb0ae80", "version_title": "William Davidson Edition - English", "hebrew_version_title": "William Davidson Edition - Vocalized Aramaic" } }, { "id": "MAIMONIDES", "title": "Mishneh Torah, Repentance 5:1", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Mishneh_Torah%2C_Repentance.5.1", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Mishneh_Torah%2C_Repentance.5.1", "sha256": "ac9d8f5af0a868877debfa75a3e1964567bf4103fa018d57b743df252c58d05f", "bytes": 102422, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Specified canonical passage in Hebrew/Aramaic and available English translation through the library public text API. Ordinary HTML route returns an application shell.", "original_markers": [ "turn23search2" ], "alternate_access": { "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/api/texts/Mishneh_Torah%2C_Repentance.5.1?context=0&commentary=0", "sha256": "6a26d0119e9c7a6d7d0a6b27d5d3133f0f6048493a6f58783e35073ab128f1c3", "version_title": "Mishneh Torah, trans. by Eliyahu Touger. Jerusalem, Moznaim Pub. c1986-c2007", "hebrew_version_title": "Torat Emet 363" } }, { "id": "ONKELOS", "title": "Onkelos on Genesis 2:7", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Onkelos_Genesis.2.7", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Onkelos_Genesis.2.7", "sha256": "50e366180fb412250f568dad9e6df139ac32a4647339869c339bfeede4aad545", "bytes": 69699, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Specified canonical passage in Hebrew/Aramaic and available English translation through the library public text API. Ordinary HTML route returns an application shell.", "original_markers": [ "turn23search25" ], "alternate_access": { "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/api/texts/Onkelos_Genesis.2.7?context=0&commentary=0", "sha256": "d8f47999e9d067b07d8a72935707ad5703092c6d5443a43689b640783d2c3990", "version_title": "Metsudah Chumash, Metsudah Publications, 2009 [with Onkelos translation]", "hebrew_version_title": "Sifsei Chachomim Chumash, Metsudah Publications, 2009" } }, { "id": "RASHI", "title": "Rashi on Genesis 2:7", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Rashi_on_Genesis.2.7", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Rashi_on_Genesis.2.7", "sha256": "1b4a696f3009e6108d88f7966f4106a31494d8936b05199d04c180e8981feabe", "bytes": 64508, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Specified canonical passage in Hebrew/Aramaic and available English translation through the library public text API. Ordinary HTML route returns an application shell.", "original_markers": [ "turn23search21" ], "alternate_access": { "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/api/texts/Rashi_on_Genesis.2.7?context=0&commentary=0", "sha256": "8381e08de00421449063ffa25d3852586dd02677bfd83f786cbc01817277f3e7", "version_title": null, "hebrew_version_title": "Pentateuch with Rashi's commentary by M. Rosenbaum and A.M. Silbermann, 1929-1934" } }, { "id": "HARRIS-ABSTRACT-PDF", "title": "Public Spring 2026 article abstracts", "url": "https://traditiononline.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Abstracts0262-0267.pdf", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://traditiononline.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Abstracts0262-0267.pdf", "sha256": "5942304cfec3c4834f42965dfb70ed89d13be7626c59a97414dc9681e097b483", "bytes": 134674, "content_type": "application/pdf", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Public issue abstracts, printed p.263 (PDF p.2), Harris paragraph. Does not support specific ritual/minyan claims in the original report.", "original_markers": [] }, { "id": "NAVON-CREATE-PUBLISHED", "title": "Navon, Let Us Make Man in Our Image, published article", "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-023-00328-y", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-023-00328-y?error=cookies_not_supported&code=08b7995f-d0f8-4085-b876-df26aa15d2da", "sha256": "2dd10dca1881743b1192fed4a63fd8e9e8137a958fb9362e66c695f21140b386", "bytes": 642352, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn14search1" ] }, { "id": "NAVON-SERVANT", "title": "Navon, The Virtuous Servant Owner", "url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frobt.2021.715849/full", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/robotics-and-ai/articles/10.3389/frobt.2021.715849/full", "sha256": "f8bfc13bd1cee9e333abe766a6d5a1afba6460281bdc31bf8668a5ebf7e72fc3", "bytes": 1138449, "content_type": "text/html;charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn16search19" ] }, { "id": "AVRAHAM", "title": "Michael Avraham, Technological Phobias and AI Halakhic Rulings, column 590", "url": "https://mikyab.net/posts/82482/", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://mikyab.net/posts/82482/", "sha256": "573e811e0a033009b74e5ce7ff6141ed93a4c8b00ca65d0539418b50ea0cb96b", "bytes": 369856, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Hebrew column 590, author argument about sufficient competence, technical expertise versus formal authority and the questioner’s choice; article body separated from comments and machine-generated summaries. Contextual replacement for anonymous dissent, not authenticated original pointer identity.", "original_markers": [ "turn20search4", "turn20search10" ] }, { "id": "YU-COURSE", "title": "YU, Straus Center Course Spotlight, Ethics in Artificial Intelligence", "url": "https://www.yu.edu/news/artificial-intelligence-ethics-yeshiva-university", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://www.yu.edu/news/artificial-intelligence-ethics-yeshiva-university", "sha256": "78c4af8068d80bade7e9203468952388b00d6394e97e9c52941cba38c7e51ace", "bytes": 35878, "content_type": "text/html; charset=UTF-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Relevant primary article or institutional-policy passages, checked for the attributed position, practice, date or authority structure. No empirical consciousness testing or independent peer review.", "original_markers": [ "turn16search27" ] }, { "id": "LOIKE-TENDLER", "title": "Loike and Tendler, Ma Adam Va-Teda-Ehu, bibliographic record", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15468502/", "http_status": 203, "final_url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15468502/", "sha256": "50a711edefd252ab24dc73272263e77b3bbb9f0b07d0d172ef0401a16acc2d41", "bytes": 5590, "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "PubMed bibliographic metadata through the web text service after the direct route returned a cookie interstitial (HTTP 203), including authors, Summer 2003, volume/issue and pages. Philosophical applications were checked through Navon, not independently from the original article.", "original_markers": [ "turn13search1" ] }, { "id": "LAMM", "title": "Lamm, The Religious Implications of Extraterrestrial Life", "url": "https://traditiononline.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/The-Religious-Implication.pdf", "http_status": 200, "final_url": "https://traditiononline.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/The-Religious-Implication.pdf", "sha256": "9ef0eb8d4dea86734c28cc1048545e3411306e28ac382394435f6124912b2216", "bytes": 3562288, "content_type": "application/pdf", "checked_on": "2026-10-21", "reading_depth": "Primary essay, selected pp.20–23 (PDF pp.16–19) on human uniqueness, imago Dei and extraterrestrial intelligence. Not an AI ruling.", "original_markers": [] } ], "original_marker_dispositions": [ { "original_marker": "turn1search0", "original_occurrences": 5, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn1search4", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS-RECORD", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/node/48892" }, { "original_marker": "turn19search0", "original_occurrences": 4, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CJLS-AUTHORITY", "url": "https://rabbinicalassembly.org/resources/committee-jewish-law-and-standards" }, { "original_marker": "turn3view2", "original_occurrences": 21, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn3view1", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn4view0", "original_occurrences": 13, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn23search3", "original_occurrences": 10, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "SANHEDRIN", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.65b.17" }, { "original_marker": "turn23search7", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "SANHEDRIN", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.65b.17" }, { "original_marker": "turn3view0", "original_occurrences": 4, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn4view2", "original_occurrences": 19, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn11view3", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "reading_boundary": "The supplied report attributed detailed claims to Harris. Only publisher metadata and the public abstract were checked; related arguments are supported from Navon where possible. The specific minyan interpretation was excluded, not inferred from the abstract." }, { "original_marker": "turn12view0", "original_occurrences": 9, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "reading_boundary": "The supplied report attributed detailed claims to Harris. Only publisher metadata and the public abstract were checked; related arguments are supported from Navon where possible. The specific minyan interpretation was excluded, not inferred from the abstract." }, { "original_marker": "turn17view1", "original_occurrences": 5, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-THESIS", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/Misc/TheMoralStatusOfAI_Thesis_MoisNavon_V5.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn18view0", "original_occurrences": 9, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-THESIS", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/Misc/TheMoralStatusOfAI_Thesis_MoisNavon_V5.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn18view1", "original_occurrences": 31, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-THESIS", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/Misc/TheMoralStatusOfAI_Thesis_MoisNavon_V5.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn16search25", "original_occurrences": 6, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn21view0", "original_occurrences": 26, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "TZOHAR", "url": "https://ethics.tzohar.org.il/en/using-artificial-intelligence-systems-to-rule-halacha-abridged-position-paper/" }, { "original_marker": "turn22search0", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "TZOHAR", "url": "https://ethics.tzohar.org.il/en/using-artificial-intelligence-systems-to-rule-halacha-abridged-position-paper/" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search2", "original_occurrences": 15, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CCAR-AI", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/5784-2-artificial-intelligence-and-authorship/" }, { "original_marker": "turn7view1", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CCAR-AI", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/5784-2-artificial-intelligence-and-authorship/" }, { "original_marker": "turn7view2", "original_occurrences": 4, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CCAR-AI", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/5784-2-artificial-intelligence-and-authorship/" }, { "original_marker": "turn19search1", "original_occurrences": 4, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CCAR-AUTONOMY", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/nyp-no-5761-3/" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search8", "original_occurrences": 4, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CCAR-AUTONOMY", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/ccar-responsa/nyp-no-5761-3/" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search1", "original_occurrences": 9, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "SMUHA-NEWS", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/news/what-it-means-to-be-human-in-an-algorithmized-world/" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search4", "original_occurrences": 4, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "MARCUS-POWER", "url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/the-power-and-danger-of-artificial-intelligence/" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search18", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "EVOLVE-TECH", "url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/category/technology/" }, { "original_marker": "turn23search0", "original_occurrences": 7, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "GENESIS-IMAGE", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Genesis.1.26-27" }, { "original_marker": "turn23search1", "original_occurrences": 5, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "GENESIS-BREATH", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Genesis.2.7" }, { "original_marker": "turn23search2", "original_occurrences": 12, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "MAIMONIDES", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Mishneh_Torah%2C_Repentance.5.1" }, { "original_marker": "turn18view2", "original_occurrences": 11, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-THESIS", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/Misc/TheMoralStatusOfAI_Thesis_MoisNavon_V5.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn18view3", "original_occurrences": 14, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-THESIS", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/Misc/TheMoralStatusOfAI_Thesis_MoisNavon_V5.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn19search4", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CJLS-AUTHORITY", "url": "https://rabbinicalassembly.org/resources/committee-jewish-law-and-standards" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search6", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "RECON-BEHAVING", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/learn/reconstructionism-behaving/" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search11", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "RECON-FOUNDATIONS", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/article/reconstructionist-revolution-foundational-ideas/" }, { "original_marker": "turn19search19", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "unidentified incidental source; excluded as evidence", "replacement_source": null, "url": null }, { "original_marker": "turn23search25", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "ONKELOS", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Onkelos_Genesis.2.7" }, { "original_marker": "turn19search2", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "RCA-VAAD", "url": "https://rabbis.org/vaad-halachah/" }, { "original_marker": "turn22search4", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "TZOHAR", "url": "https://ethics.tzohar.org.il/en/using-artificial-intelligence-systems-to-rule-halacha-abridged-position-paper/" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search3", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "RECON-VALUES", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/article/values-based-decision-making/" }, { "original_marker": "turn22search1", "original_occurrences": 10, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "OU-OHRBIT", "url": "https://www.ou.org/news/the-orthodox-union-launches-revolutionary-ai-powered-torah-app/" }, { "original_marker": "turn22search3", "original_occurrences": 5, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "YU-EDUCATORS", "url": "https://www.yu.edu/azrieli/educators-resources" }, { "original_marker": "turn4view1", "original_occurrences": 10, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn2view0", "original_occurrences": 4, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NEVINS", "url": "https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/nevins_ai_moral_machines_and_halakha-final_1.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search10", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "SMUHA-THESIS", "url": "https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/files/nsmuha_humancondition.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn16search28", "original_occurrences": 5, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-LOVE-PUBLISHED", "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00146-025-02574-6" }, { "original_marker": "turn12view2", "original_occurrences": 10, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "reading_boundary": "The supplied report attributed detailed claims to Harris. Only publisher metadata and the public abstract were checked; related arguments are supported from Navon where possible. The specific minyan interpretation was excluded, not inferred from the abstract." }, { "original_marker": "turn13search1", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "LOIKE-TENDLER", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15468502/" }, { "original_marker": "turn16search19", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-SERVANT", "url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frobt.2021.715849/full" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search12", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "MARCUS-GOLEM", "url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/chatgpt-is-the-opposite-of-the-golem/" }, { "original_marker": "turn14search1", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-CREATE-PUBLISHED", "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-023-00328-y" }, { "original_marker": "turn16search13", "original_occurrences": 3, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-EUDEMONIA", "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-024-00553-z" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search5", "original_occurrences": 5, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "CCAR-JOURNAL", "url": "https://www.ccarnet.org/the-reform-jewish-quarterly-fall-2025/" }, { "original_marker": "turn21view1", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "TZOHAR", "url": "https://ethics.tzohar.org.il/en/using-artificial-intelligence-systems-to-rule-halacha-abridged-position-paper/" }, { "original_marker": "turn10search3", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "HARRIS-RECORD", "url": "https://traditiononline.org/becoming-one-like-us-jewish-tradition-and-artificial-intelligence/" }, { "original_marker": "turn10search1", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "HARRIS-RECORD", "url": "https://traditiononline.org/becoming-one-like-us-jewish-tradition-and-artificial-intelligence/" }, { "original_marker": "turn22search5", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "JTS-EVENTS", "url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/event/future-torah-jewish-learning-age-ai/" }, { "original_marker": "turn11view2", "original_occurrences": 6, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "reading_boundary": "The supplied report attributed detailed claims to Harris. Only publisher metadata and the public abstract were checked; related arguments are supported from Navon where possible. The specific minyan interpretation was excluded, not inferred from the abstract." }, { "original_marker": "turn23search21", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "RASHI", "url": "https://www.sefaria.org/Rashi_on_Genesis.2.7" }, { "original_marker": "turn11view1", "original_occurrences": 5, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "reading_boundary": "The supplied report attributed detailed claims to Harris. Only publisher metadata and the public abstract were checked; related arguments are supported from Navon where possible. The specific minyan interpretation was excluded, not inferred from the abstract." }, { "original_marker": "turn12view1", "original_occurrences": 10, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "reading_boundary": "The supplied report attributed detailed claims to Harris. Only publisher metadata and the public abstract were checked; related arguments are supported from Navon where possible. The specific minyan interpretation was excluded, not inferred from the abstract." }, { "original_marker": "turn12view3", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "NAVON-OXFORD", "url": "https://www.divreinavon.com/pdf/Navon_AI_PersonhoodaJewishPerspective_ACCEPTED_MANUSCRIPT.pdf", "reading_boundary": "The supplied report attributed detailed claims to Harris. Only publisher metadata and the public abstract were checked; related arguments are supported from Navon where possible. The specific minyan interpretation was excluded, not inferred from the abstract." }, { "original_marker": "turn16search27", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "YU-COURSE", "url": "https://www.yu.edu/news/artificial-intelligence-ethics-yeshiva-university" }, { "original_marker": "turn22search2", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "JTS-2024", "url": "https://www.jtsa.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Student-Information-and-Policies-AY-24-25.pdf" }, { "original_marker": "turn15search7", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "EVOLVE-TECH", "url": "https://evolve.reconstructingjudaism.org/category/technology/" }, { "original_marker": "turn20search4", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "AVRAHAM", "url": "https://mikyab.net/posts/82482/", "reading_boundary": "An identified primary Michael Avraham argument supports the revised individual-dissent claim; the original anonymous pointers are not authenticated." }, { "original_marker": "turn20search10", "original_occurrences": 1, "status": "contextual support reconstructed; original-session identity unauthenticated", "replacement_source": "AVRAHAM", "url": "https://mikyab.net/posts/82482/", "reading_boundary": "An identified primary Michael Avraham argument supports the revised individual-dissent claim; the original anonymous pointers are not authenticated." } ], "unrecovered_markers": [ { "original_marker": "turn19search19", "original_occurrences": 2, "status": "unidentified incidental source; excluded as evidence", "replacement_source": null, "url": null } ], "unavailable_attachments": [ "Authenticated original provider session, source URL export and search log", "Harris full article through the checked public access route" ], "source_preservation": { "original_public": false, "original_words": 11605, "publication_words": 13729, "original_sections": [ "Findings, scope, and authority", "Current positions and historical development", "Theological foundations and artificial minds", "Moral standing, agency, creation, relationship, and identity", "Practice, debate, cases, and pressure points", "Comparative Matrix", "Open questions, claim matrix, and sources" ], "original_table_structure": [ { "ordinal": 1, "rows": 6, "columns": 3, "sha256": "cc303d3ffb68ff4d3d5d5ad3e8bc625c81071219e022d483729a7625d48648ce" }, { "ordinal": 2, "rows": 13, "columns": 3, "sha256": "b4cfe84171168869fb302f07d5309026237c09d86aa92fb8d1f9386e8160822e" }, { "ordinal": 3, "rows": 19, "columns": 3, "sha256": "36ce4bf0091adbad0b1b9bdb8c3226678b526ccc65f3d8e94d01fe70cc7402c3" }, { "ordinal": 4, "rows": 9, "columns": 2, "sha256": "3c38d6bc01c0bf66ed70787da85d5847a8bfdb1ac4927f7c1b4379f0d55cf7e0" }, { "ordinal": 5, "rows": 7, "columns": 2, "sha256": "03d9091abf424335e34f3d00cb80cd949cde0b3feeb42d4df70d1e3d2b25e8d8" }, { "ordinal": 6, "rows": 6, "columns": 5, "sha256": "0c58995891b94f3ccaf7eea28e202aea5fe52913b755e477948d5336b5f9d461" }, { "ordinal": 7, "rows": 14, "columns": 2, "sha256": "47a6037efd3a1bec5955b137b780ba95157235df1bb9619d54828218eb72ea03" }, { "ordinal": 8, "rows": 18, "columns": 4, "sha256": "75f4524c4c3270b6d9f8fb433d608889183238a644314eee5c0d385e155eb40e" }, { "ordinal": 9, "rows": 17, "columns": 6, "sha256": "5beacf114ad57c3e45935b61154e2c07dd49e6e8eb0a9660034f06a93376698a" } ], "reviewed_table_structure": [ { "ordinal": 1, "rows": 6, "columns": 3, "sha256": "35f40ccd4d41d9cdc28196a6d9974d699f1af907ec6325e875f106ad3cf83f67" }, { "ordinal": 2, "rows": 13, "columns": 3, "sha256": "054937f869956b2d19434f4352da7e4786b96c0511eb34f02d4b3064aac6f03a" }, { "ordinal": 3, "rows": 19, "columns": 3, "sha256": "477ff505a059c5d65385687fb221a707cf57bf0aab81c6b9d71c7b597a3e3122" }, { "ordinal": 4, "rows": 9, "columns": 2, "sha256": "3bb8c9b5b2d4345d34b123d0effbf91b8da3b85ad7c1385b44fb9c2bcf03896c" }, { "ordinal": 5, "rows": 7, "columns": 2, "sha256": "904feb457847807407b4ce3f11333c97feb1c1b9223e70974753a448f20ea050" }, { "ordinal": 6, "rows": 6, "columns": 5, "sha256": "632e7027102832b2dd7423c0155551cc6431db96ea97c9d6169531468ea44bb8" }, { "ordinal": 7, "rows": 14, "columns": 2, "sha256": "fa12d97568f84ef95a8b287928779499380648503904994d9a19c1fbfcf33423" }, { "ordinal": 8, "rows": 18, "columns": 3, "sha256": "052d100da51720e200687ca0d4137c1ebfd2b3ee663305b8e220df00bfef67bb" }, { "ordinal": 9, "rows": 17, "columns": 5, "sha256": "e3c622dbb71a1c5ae1794b453ccccd0390fdfaa8bb19568ff9bd8f57991b94ed" } ], "unit_dispositions": [ { "ordinal": 1, "sha256": "cf613bf4b5a8d64facaebea287493924986766c6a4102ae68abd43ba243f62f2", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 2, "sha256": "6d225ddee1ad5b45cae5ed514f0c8225100adc714cb156d52c13020c191e677d", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 3, "sha256": "1328dcf4a45b2fa6acaa13cd74d5fd6f80e0c2aec20f9edef25d058c4af03489", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 4, "sha256": "6b34fbaecebd52d64be4dc2cecdff0dcf4434c17373637d1c58c959a5ae82e11", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 5, "sha256": "666f45f086ab3636ddc66dc2f7d0717847c62731489ca6ec323c8e8e3b2c4d49", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 6, "sha256": "cfd92179ec4dddb1e5dd9a73553da51d9a0611d02ed12c1dd051b1e75bbb6594", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 7, "sha256": "bfcb232497137532dc696df2783d2df08f46b46757179c1538437e6cf3a5150f", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 8, "sha256": "10848ed49f8a6b7f50269cca538dba031bfcdfb7d2f8661a4a4baa6e7640fff2", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 9, "sha256": "af37563663aa95818b6dd35e038d88240b27cebc707788522c4a8471d0476976", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 10, "sha256": "7d5b723d04099f407c6a279f8f209e412977aa0ede4c17668fed3da4c74a3768", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 11, "sha256": "f38683567a940126491ce9d35d4caedd88d751b455d2c13a5e0861e3618fd86d", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 12, "sha256": "3b72ed2440629eb5606b1dd73d868f7c7add6c5c093ad362de33cb3c3c661dfb", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 13, "sha256": "8067c0927b7312026cd33ded00ec65780a153b5777a1f064478ba8af9c8f16ee", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 14, "sha256": "881bc0c1a699f7c06270ddccb1ab1975b967b918d0842cc1b22bbbddf6a5abca", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 15, "sha256": "f3dcbe486106a39a94258d18541b7def9d14848b6da6e3235bcb7e592e7abb37", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 16, "sha256": "4ffe69bf2e1b6b76dac8c682d75356a0deed0e53ba0373cc04a012ecf67d63d5", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 17, "sha256": "cc303d3ffb68ff4d3d5d5ad3e8bc625c81071219e022d483729a7625d48648ce", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 18, "sha256": "0f7b4dabef25961b9ed67da6d97feec059cf007e8ef77df0ef53c3ec9de317e3", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 19, "sha256": "82620a33d78e56507be634631375f60fc360794b4c3b44598167bae31f325787", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 20, "sha256": "5d6e7aeb9b3cc8917c30c5291f4970d54d7fc7be94dd3c81cee936bbf048917a", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 21, "sha256": "12cffe07d68ebdd79d377c22c342fe640237d06ef446bbac877e80762aa5a6b5", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 22, "sha256": "744d066ef6d1707787e1b2611f206bba10b78b0448e53deef066dcd89b15ea60", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 23, "sha256": "24ced5849ebb113ca875e63f646baeceb0820cbf2d857837e918feadeb2aeb2d", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 24, "sha256": "3bd0bedd4352932b257b02febc515a2d7699fb6a32a506bb03f49660567be9f4", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 25, "sha256": "4bb1e30782275eb31762ad6ca171480bfc283cd7e512aa068eb4f1eebf9825d6", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 26, "sha256": "298cf160b2f93320ae92996ac95565d94f8511227a8cd5ddf34a5a5868735b89", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 27, "sha256": "347cd10d4d30b6b6f14be344569329e886533ed855e39afb18bbd943f2f8bc2d", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 28, "sha256": "b4cfe84171168869fb302f07d5309026237c09d86aa92fb8d1f9386e8160822e", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 29, "sha256": "fc0c974a7c6527b418d91b72fded5bda260e9e442411d9d9954514f225a06468", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 30, "sha256": "e0c5b076b206061ad2b6afae0b93e02a2b5675eaed7a62801a7ffcadcd50f848", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 31, "sha256": "36ce4bf0091adbad0b1b9bdb8c3226678b526ccc65f3d8e94d01fe70cc7402c3", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 32, "sha256": "3ce7e7dd185ab75b3bfcf0e2777bb43c112d5009d6968a4941ef39a3dac476ec", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 33, "sha256": "0a054df5238367c842ea497bac896ada1f17b70b548790c28e3c70c2c1abaf0d", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 34, "sha256": "491f786815b6f53d765460ea4cd41531b6bb735c2d66760d2abbc4a666912389", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 35, "sha256": "5d066ced02ebb6f2b949295a5e29238b73690da1f24cc9076d29f96b12a81af6", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 36, "sha256": "094ee94b7b291685f518950c761b05107e358c134a281a3b926b96e1df608ddf", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 37, "sha256": "92b071fd5779b794d2915e75c6fb55f7687e6f3e13dfd6c18b1dfa7cdf8583af", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 38, "sha256": "69683ea8e0164ab306212751214843d600a558179a98224a94fd3cd81ad5c006", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 39, "sha256": "05d67c7295884dd7a2ed5db57d712cd6a06731b3f9e05285c5c23e7f27bc169b", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 40, "sha256": "032104cbb57a37f3a16cb561bed1da1d43f558ecf17b62035b014c5220825b37", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 41, "sha256": "9645a15e0cada11bcb2a2f8672391362319d5a56437dd78465f86fa1fa64774b", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 42, "sha256": "f37e1fffd8811d6faba003afa1968c63f57a6ef3545968b7757b99f644815f70", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 43, "sha256": "0869c9658cb01d56f9ecb6e39326b09e402033cdb2935894526f159dc3918d35", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 44, "sha256": "07a593138fa40177bf93d93711b50412ba5b2eb52d00d9c6be690b88bd944275", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 45, "sha256": "7342346ac0ebe7a192a0146ea27c0bed792bf1d1161fb98f95d29a59e8b74d2b", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 46, "sha256": "2693695652ec60efccacbfa485ec896f6f2020da9ab3de18409df54dc1b971b3", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 47, "sha256": "784c154518a3da04d92aa3e2e1c58b49aa35adde9db404b7a857a1ac5331f884", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 48, "sha256": "1c3b0e2e320ab75b3e71ac550d0c5a653a000c25ee1d2f09edeb41c89825fa72", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 49, "sha256": "bb8c22a8d59a1e50131d599e0dddd07c0d14ce1bb040e8dbf348214982813fcf", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 50, "sha256": "731f3cd06db4d1de1b87f82062a7916d0521987e378c604cf920430fa2ddce49", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 51, "sha256": "3c38d6bc01c0bf66ed70787da85d5847a8bfdb1ac4927f7c1b4379f0d55cf7e0", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 52, "sha256": "8eb29b798a16cffbb9a8f29fc3d3c1af5bb0ae34884f9e55db06333891d55029", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 53, "sha256": "edcd9408f8c3d6add69b91781853f6d15234dc44a2b1b6be2d64ea495eef5afa", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 54, "sha256": "b03aba482b8a8fc28bfd7e2772c98338a5782cae238bc4136f0bf2dcfe4c04ae", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 55, "sha256": "91838acfc7ea84d1fc7c438d83012d266145cc184068b7e2b2ffd3b1b979f9c3", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 56, "sha256": "df0d66a6fdb8e4b33b6654afd6c1356a90cd517a70c5a32a0ad9e9d66418a9f4", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 57, "sha256": "87c922a1314a32876c48bc7167c685f2325f0c6b7f2327b5fb2b122a013d7adf", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 58, "sha256": "a1742ab0c4033598234a6833537630a9a89ab6ba226e96e110ad7b08ad1ba878", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 59, "sha256": "82a9cf05a2b2e26bd4b4077a6679f7e83f63624ac118a5cd646d918197a89511", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 60, "sha256": "3e76080825ce772fa508a7e692591deb6d981140f82a19a8a966a7985ee1fb28", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 61, "sha256": "68d832f80ef51defbe5d15fcc3039c8ea3a12f0b25c498e6985e6238687de0bf", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 62, "sha256": "746b6865a4121c44245ff227dfb7788df3bff80ac6d92abc0e5765b2b1d9ae37", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 63, "sha256": "3e7e0f7ab2dfa9f5a400a3cb810e1823402b11f3c612cd19dae9c7adf27e55fb", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 64, "sha256": "d0e59ebd62b444d4b960a08cac3f2043675b0e8ef3d2d400fd9a0c944f2f0ecd", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 65, "sha256": "d9cb497d1b6dfbd3d652e48b1a7082b0aeccf676219ffe896a2ad5d1a4cbdeeb", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 66, "sha256": "b85aa9cada0f53abe0196703d38f488ef5cd56fc987d76060d8fc92a1ea431de", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 67, "sha256": "16f7123be13f87f1556372e4fdc6c2e06629ef029a926954c218c240ad984505", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 68, "sha256": "9ce14198529db5ea966f0a15cb7d465259e7c2e8145dcbcda62490125bdc9841", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 69, "sha256": "efd817d41d9a7253478f461cdff206c27c59f5ab93ea9cc841b1acaa7b504151", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 70, "sha256": "4367e5898fc7bcf4e49e1e6d83dda0e1191f479ba29ba69be9d544dfa25ca1d6", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 71, "sha256": "c45b15af29bb2a5774da64b11c52fe2297f9388697f81cb1843cfe8874963345", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 72, "sha256": "c192f09d363a57535caf6af0cae82a532d68a6cf1d36a1829fd4893a63f8a5d4", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 73, "sha256": "47198f4534e93071e8ac5ef65cc0c86baa5954d480962043e22391fe83d3db4a", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 74, "sha256": "672560cb6062388d1282c4e146b8ef37dc12e188df3c3635c95497a001c2c21f", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 75, "sha256": "c1122212b503cf9ae289b78eb56166d0c66df1e0390bab6a33422372936a2a3f", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 76, "sha256": "43ff7a9fa9a677543e31477d789f1adfefe7ac3c785bb8993b1a6f6974f63e2c", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 77, "sha256": "eb011e2fefc8848a47d1e61775a1c7f44dc38203d1e59d5fb67ab08b46c0f8b7", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 78, "sha256": "596f6e42f06c580ed8cf33a32b6ecf374ce52571df4f344ab392be49b68c2058", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 79, "sha256": "699462f02420e5b41307a0aa5c254fd4050ec11e212a6aee4d479483b521abaa", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 80, "sha256": "c66cc3b28eb4d3823cfa944306a994cb509b15378ceea47cb3e283fd7adbac72", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 81, "sha256": "b6e57cab150940c35406810375b240b3e7016337fdbdbaaf18457978fc5adc31", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 82, "sha256": "fa223fae148234913e4ed33dd5b7cedc3370aa0598850df5e805c9ba69d026fd", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 83, "sha256": "852f06398ab42cb4096d8e462d1c243d2091ac5d1d874579c3f6c1b5d3648466", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 84, "sha256": "7b8185fa7b29371a85d7e2403f4755127110d5f1ee63c74580751d0b8a4e5fff", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 85, "sha256": "c741c97138565b59a4e4b26b1e032716678fd8000b7c9132f1d04e3f5a9941e6", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 86, "sha256": "b1d013e6a02e0aed06bead6ddbd30eada9795327e7bf35212f2a6fd86f5fe4ab", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 87, "sha256": "d80a19478a7d70a1eb2249a9ea00320ce54d184fdeb0676933f18ebd258763e7", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 88, "sha256": "4ccdbe13123ee15c8e241f88b04d86c096518b931c0c1a3b811b42adb080cff8", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 89, "sha256": "259bd020994093630a956b814fa4771e5ca968a20ac87a650e576c0ad58e13b2", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 90, "sha256": "5525715b48f64c7adf058564649befe00b92944d9ea7b31d168cae9c01f30e90", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 91, "sha256": "4426f37756d99313994ca57cd4e60efe5ee312905f43a83818e98b838876ed59", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 92, "sha256": "19c85f94878012e08b7eb974b82587bd87dd3cb2fa7863e8ae60928234be91cc", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 93, "sha256": "4d4ad66ec4767c326d46242307484496042aebbac88ecd75d6c018bac5557b88", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 94, "sha256": "5a2a59b057e84badde1a37b071e8c04170f7c986d483cb499e8d01068dc4411e", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 95, "sha256": "ba064ef14d260af94520696cd6750502b94468caa808290035358806b3816936", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 96, "sha256": "03d9091abf424335e34f3d00cb80cd949cde0b3feeb42d4df70d1e3d2b25e8d8", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 97, "sha256": "c708345ed22c47bc0aeb5a24ec9a27d9430470167ee158e936a045ff0ed20368", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 98, "sha256": "9422b3c31cf474a500ac6e26b5fcc5947aa39d87090eedabf6df2d31e9f21834", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 99, "sha256": "e6f6fcd9905ed13648d77878a29cbec6b1ffba1e3c48eb9bc30b1a234b6e7576", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 100, "sha256": "66432ee2cdb9e23885cc4ba8e0bf8d2664406ebf82d155ad623084a9c87e45bb", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 101, "sha256": "3a7643e2c95158be631c9691772f09770547be10d1005c0788461322cbd67fc4", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 102, "sha256": "d8a7cddb2f85136395877a3223762957bb774d803e7dedba4c2a253bb9a3ccd4", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 103, "sha256": "a98a561c9375dcc77751a4d0b3ce6b17290910aae093d3c617d409a9d2e061ec", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 104, "sha256": "6c2c90ee1a7ad8568ab434fba8c70ffb68b1c17eb2abf77813e51d20cf44dd0c", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 105, "sha256": "b78c3f480d586030095d4700de6910bad448abfd7711e678b600eaeeede921e4", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 106, "sha256": "f5efd13c4ad7bc0f355e26e34ccc6da9ac4b5364112110d0f82cd8cfe66d3477", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 107, "sha256": "41f7913f3a4217dc7ff7e0cb99acf1b3ee40b344c7cb4e2271f8030bc6d2af32", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 108, "sha256": "727e3c1ef72560706c7d9ae5c5a95adb79e8524ded3c304d9f3e5725441495cc", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 109, "sha256": "c91cf60169026240ae4052959d7265593d4e58e06985b152f562c5aa133b8aec", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 110, "sha256": "6b69203c459957adfcb1ee22e93a3d708ae2fedd363364d0b57365e62864bc78", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 111, "sha256": "19cc17f8fb362053cf7f7fbfadacf660cf725af87bb7d725c7a53f0ba0c90d52", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 112, "sha256": "f260f1057a42fa643e340b9dc52ad232a6a37220b869edda87c5c97890d3f58b", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 113, "sha256": "143def34d3268140fd85058d396c5a0dd237600a1e1c0a0ba6880a68d580379c", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 114, "sha256": "85fa1a8b7b76d8377a893fcb07fc59a4c106d6c2e7289b7457c3241e1abd2729", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 115, "sha256": "aa78bba55588ab72401549eda103451a742821bc3f159596f62b8710aea51619", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 116, "sha256": "72647cff20f8a139588c5401d359abf96f120ea4df9a99a81facbaf7caf9fe51", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 117, "sha256": "4a27badf4841daeea38fa9b02210e31b09e3fde70b65ff4a938d2ea48b0eefb2", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 118, "sha256": "08da320de3770185e524e2d2b659150c2317bb62df4a1152900e67781e4f2344", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 119, "sha256": "eb2220874f1b79e4eaf6295a745a962f9db37a32c00cf17ee6b0c354c5129358", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 120, "sha256": "14fb8a8cd3870b46dbb0b4fc0f59359d7663ccf2bc18a0f8b9ec1b1726e0dea8", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 121, "sha256": "4e1fc0a0b53ed3504de798f32b19d311d7c82232c9a858bb0220cddc6b425402", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 122, "sha256": "da1638334a94618228c77b2c4c8d2cc8d261033564dfe84f38caea94666ed248", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 123, "sha256": "dd7561269721224e3674c6d2a6e80388d5a2989b6b0be1add6671a8f3d73ea06", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 124, "sha256": "7fad181470a75ec83e0209b1615718a079c1b9d67f815a1a1991327ddb45ad7a", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 125, "sha256": "1e0304197a4dcb0b2491a435b584860d1438d33deedea1b4a7428dd43abddecd", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 126, "sha256": "8d1632539b35528b4b39031de064242c3a3541b8fa7ad4cc495874a4e64c813e", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 127, "sha256": "3c447447d2209ad18af9c6cc3d071df14783516f033e12e0f05992ea87c911a9", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 128, "sha256": "e046ab0abfdd3cf03abea3b8a49e4b603fe799b1c83bc4c744a14dbe50be64fa", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 129, "sha256": "0c58995891b94f3ccaf7eea28e202aea5fe52913b755e477948d5336b5f9d461", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 130, "sha256": "b4cdf52dc46392ee23e7878ff7952ea7eb798131ef9d9e2da50cebf5c4432ae7", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 131, "sha256": "e33795b231207edafcfe7e2c64becfb314e979edfdf4848c2f322386a994b816", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 132, "sha256": "d8668b12e0978e66475236c45cc74cb83b46864f4d85bcb608a82b0c3afe1e66", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 133, "sha256": "47a6037efd3a1bec5955b137b780ba95157235df1bb9619d54828218eb72ea03", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 134, "sha256": "d8c792140e40dc4bd3348ff4d8fc4cb0267f1c91a1974aab4ff211a77290daae", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 135, "sha256": "d0ee5e054d821fee197418025f50af676283672eb13afe21c6a7842eda71f039", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 136, "sha256": "b9d40b69ee0c8dfabcf92096839aa9d3a3f2edc28f6fed7e5f72a111c4c10156", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 137, "sha256": "6c1383adeacf55c22f86403461a53171751cac4e58d07017570a21ba7b8228d6", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 138, "sha256": "cafaf7b578f70c22c2ee143e507f701a93101bb45c2b3a02e10828163731c74e", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 139, "sha256": "374707e521a9f17a249b6c0b226d1153714815b70bdec08a5c5ea1db65852f0e", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 140, "sha256": "eb5e20d435d88cd9b0ab0636cdbd5186a0ac4b5e5216e296f7d654c973485f8f", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 141, "sha256": "4c1c3a55f8c977ffeab03027982d9ba9886841d09218ab4fdf63353b615bd964", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 142, "sha256": "f36d4dcda88205805f512427948ad6b12fc35523a2b21ff4870ece7470f7a6bb", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 143, "sha256": "d49fb5e08ef84886a3f8a6cfbdb5730aafa592695b552316db5d6d68d44c6aff", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 144, "sha256": "f925ba75fa3c424cf7102f80e772d98c3df853c2ee3d18a5893480694ab6e938", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 145, "sha256": "37e9fdade1603a6852773ccdd504c987501f3e47bf2c0f3ebdc8dfb9e543625a", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 146, "sha256": "75f4524c4c3270b6d9f8fb433d608889183238a644314eee5c0d385e155eb40e", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 147, "sha256": "41d3e7cafdedec8c560e8d89025d2662c029548352c05eb13a41e887883cfe86", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 148, "sha256": "d23a425b796ffdb3b09fa67242c34b5c93e8bdec314a787270deddaa38c33546", "kind": "heading", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 149, "sha256": "7e37bd62f6df67aac2e8c6ace3ad87a265483e5de4163f747c56157b68f0ff7d", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 150, "sha256": "43d67b80fb58a2ba24787622e9a5434ff8dcdfdba57feafecac5519fd54975cd", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 151, "sha256": "ce04a0fef494933d7b7435e7eae44e24b104f069933a60b9d00536808fba3bee", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 152, "sha256": "5f45f3a24c0ffd5e65b39c449e3b3485df819f995bb32e5b7dbbce1ea7b064cd", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 153, "sha256": "2825ea908eb754cfdaa4013557a258d8a8e26d667e55b6b1a4840ac16931ba7b", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 154, "sha256": "8be9f7df9d4358347e6cc8cea761a88eb9598618fa3466c6502a33f66dce252d", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 155, "sha256": "1054b23b1ffd3435e60e162d826a745393cdecb1f6d29adb49cbea0348429611", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 156, "sha256": "dd3c9f9ad34be2cb39217628cc1faca0af833b3214d7a271900d7faac67ffe17", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 157, "sha256": "5e94b6c76b01cbe405a7341c65dd08493cb1cd026ac8df11707e8083ad5f455b", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 158, "sha256": "0dfce5c9e55fa860356e278e8a0a47a4d0414fed66ea20d56cb8f219fc9db2ef", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 159, "sha256": "5beacf114ad57c3e45935b61154e2c07dd49e6e8eb0a9660034f06a93376698a", "kind": "table", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 160, "sha256": "a32c787a97cec704b0067fdec81753a9c1a6c1802ae2ae3d531b4225813336fd", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 161, "sha256": "f4f0078b335207f789f44852e58be57ec36d2c5770cd8409bf89bedb217acc4b", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 162, "sha256": "e3476a8696c149fe8202cc4d26274fb9dc609aac5ecaf33d7a4339889ac46d46", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 163, "sha256": "41468ea59390a3028e60c7d5dcb08370eb169c29bd0b4afabce6ee813f4e188f", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 164, "sha256": "9f2ed40aa5099995abd03607581903de32e8df6ae8c6215fa3f406288e4fbbd4", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 165, "sha256": "fea05dd63e35e0a88994e33f3cc62657b93b112f772b6281bfa4a3b147fbeded", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 166, "sha256": "6527136b4c84fb18fc06e759ed43dafdfafb6fdefa4d4bb03da257b4c0dfc9a3", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 167, "sha256": "5dc6c1df1f59bca679411d82527e56c5fa89e52f6be74b3a6eb8ab96b92107ce", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 168, "sha256": "0bba9aec308276f186beaf6952d180869509df8dd55918203c70aece1750e4ea", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 169, "sha256": "14eec271c4ba3e489781be29b24a0b3b5583a45cad4ebd8ceb1fc057f376bcc9", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 170, "sha256": "318d16ac87e930c17d60e31d41451166c228b8373dda3279cfc6ae46b1d568d0", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 171, "sha256": "3e0eb6a9135fbd053e064028b79222ed9a1bc9195c5dd2fd71a74718579764bf", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 172, "sha256": "e30b33cacf87e833065db0b4da1dfed2c677d2a86906ed2f952599bafe938a55", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 173, "sha256": "238af36a1e2bb1084c394f72873331c6308aa657a6c4ed05d0c90d6ef81f4bf7", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 174, "sha256": "9589af4620ec1e3f784ca6ea203cdc450d7ef735c3137875fbcacb99ac1fe347", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 175, "sha256": "f2a03ba8f660443a2818fa0aca75c304d08b48b9f853fa2d6852b6719fc2e3ed", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 176, "sha256": "3dc6be7f40aff57f16048ab27462e7c724ce3f2256994f3898d94f2fde156ad2", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 177, "sha256": "2bfa5982468f6301a2c658ec04c9e32ba33a14e90c0920341c01137997cbfc85", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 178, "sha256": "779cc682ecc574545a9a1340d8b371f15c701e17ca05c82fe7623d49e0c08b88", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 179, "sha256": "2b5e1b55ca2b15167a0f7efa97a8c1754c56b45a81d86b07937a57177a7c0155", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 180, "sha256": "54bcd6f070bee4dfd456e1ccec64f1eadf01080932e57602f1bae02809760d13", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 181, "sha256": "52cd6ca4defc313900dcd7f5b5e9e82c34ecc29686be7b1472b5e44d8c2a99e6", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 182, "sha256": "2b67c5c17e3a3c36dd8341a3a7a26eba65b318c43d4f7938e6a0b41f65288c47", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." }, { "ordinal": 183, "sha256": "22077cd54923ca5464fa9574b542d943e667c21ab68eb29cc7f194aebd614b40", "kind": "prose", "disposition": "Topic, question or original table row retained with direct source and constitutional corrections; rejected wording remains private. See transformation reasons and edition source." } ], "policy": "Preserve source identity with private original digests and public transformations. Do not republish unreviewed rejected claims as an original-source attachment." }, "limitations": [ "The supplied export has no URLs: 217 citation groups, 66 unique opaque pointers and 380 individual pointer occurrences. Original provider session, assignment and search log unavailable; every original-session identity remains unauthenticated.", "Forty source records are independently reconstructed contextual support; 65 unique pointers receive a contextual source disposition. The incidental OU congregational-authority pointer turn19search19 remains unidentified and is excluded as evidence.", "Harris full-text access requires login. Publisher metadata and freely published abstract establish identity and broad topic only. Specific golem/minyan and other detailed attributions were not verified from that abstract. Recovered Navon/classical sources replace overlapping arguments; the named ritual attribution is excluded.", "Navon Oxford accepted manuscript and published abstract checked; direct OUP request returned 403. Versions, dissertation and later articles share author lineage and are not independent corroboration.", "Navon expressly applies safeika de-oraita le-humra to reasonable doubt about human-level consciousness; this is a scholarly application, not an adopted denominational procedure or validated empirical test. The report now preserves this stronger precautionary argument.", "Navon also argues against creating sentient humanoids, including attempts and fellowship cases, and his Oxford endnote 53 excludes marriage with humans despite conditional personhood. These restrictive arguments remain alongside recognition and protection rather than being omitted.", "Conditional personhood is not proof of technical possibility or current mentality. The 2023 creation paper includes impossibility and prohibition arguments; the later Oxford argument addresses protection if the relevant status is present or reasonably uncertain. This variation is not silently harmonized.", "Classical-text HTML routes return application shells; specified passages and translations were checked through Sefaria public text APIs. English renderings and modern applications remain interpretations; no certified translation or rabbinic adjudication is claimed.", "Loike/Tendler was checked bibliographically through PubMed; its substantive application here is mediated by Navon. Smuha and the dissertation were read selectively; journal contents establish listed topics, not the positions of unread articles.", "Institutional nonfindings are bounded to selected checked records. No exhaustive multi-language corpus survey, universal Jewish consensus, causal explanation for silence or current institutional adoption is inferred from missing material.", "English Tzohar abridgment is dated 1 Sivan 5786. Its claims about AI and responsibility are attributed positions, not experiments proving absent experience or agency. Avraham supplies named individual dissent; anonymous original pointers remain unauthenticated.", "Online publication dates and issue dates are distinguished. The JTS event is scheduled for 26 October 2026, after this review date; no completed event or outcome is claimed.", "Seven original main sections and all original table row sets retained. Uncalibrated confidence columns removed from two matrices. The original unreviewed source is not publicly hosted; hashes/unit accounting preserve lineage.", "Same author credit retained under the established workflow: OpenAI Deep Research using GPT-5 Thinking. This is facilitator-provided lineage, not an authenticated original session. Public facilitator credit is only human facilitator. No independent reviewer or complete claim-by-claim certification." ], "adversarial_checks": [ "Explicit Oxford precaution under reasonable doubt", "Creation prohibition and human-form/first-order distinctions", "Marriage restriction despite conditional personhood", "Actual Hebrew Avraham body, excluding machine-generated summary and comments", "Harris public abstract versus inaccessible detailed claims", "CJLS official approval and local decisor autonomy", "Reform nonbinding guidance and historical-policy notice", "Future event is scheduled, not completed" ] }