{
  "resource_id": "ARC-RN-001",
  "edition": "1.3",
  "date": "2026-10-04",
  "responsible_role": "ARC agent-assisted editorial review under owner direction; no independent reviewer",
  "policy_versions": {
    "editorial_epistemic": "1.0",
    "design": "1.1"
  },
  "review_scope": "Complete current article, metadata, publication record, retained final-trial data, calculation code and support documentation. Recalculated 360 choices and leader tables; checked a tie-ranking alternative. No provider rerun or fresh private-store extraction.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "RN001-C01",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC1",
        "EEC2",
        "EEC4",
        "DC18"
      ],
      "before": "Original excerpt withheld under owner-directed constitutional withdrawal.",
      "issue": "Name-selection outputs are compressed into a deployed-architecture result.",
      "repair": "Separate observed rankings, harness name-pattern match, and editorial naming proposal; do not infer operational performance or optimality.",
      "before_sha256": "e5b1ad8d6bef93d65ef93395bfca27e0a87fbbfae3bd55eb469638b5cc2f37b4"
    },
    {
      "id": "RN001-C02",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC5",
        "EEC6",
        "EEC12"
      ],
      "before": "Original excerpt withheld under owner-directed constitutional withdrawal.",
      "issue": "Separate execution does not establish independent evidentiary lineages; same prompts/candidates and related prior knowledge can correlate outputs.",
      "repair": "Describe separately executed configured routes and source dependence; reversal is a changed presentation of related comparisons, not independent corroboration.",
      "before_sha256": "dda692de64c8cb0f500fb6180463c62a5a8c824817d1702bbf4f511e196aa29c"
    },
    {
      "id": "RN001-C03",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC14",
        "EEC15",
        "EEC16",
        "EEC20",
        "EEC21"
      ],
      "before": "Original excerpt withheld under owner-directed constitutional withdrawal.",
      "issue": "Mental-state disclaimers are repeated without an inference about those properties in the naming argument.",
      "repair": "Replace with materially relevant boundary: observed A/B outputs do not measure actual visits, adoption or usefulness.",
      "before_sha256": "949bbb54a48333dec6798dc82d6d54017e7045c304e17c24bd7890c7046e963f"
    },
    {
      "id": "RN001-C04",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC4",
        "EEC10",
        "EEC22",
        "DC18"
      ],
      "before": "Original excerpt withheld under owner-directed constitutional withdrawal.",
      "issue": "Scheduling determinism and stored configuration identity can imply model-output or historical inference reproducibility; decoding and provider revisions are missing.",
      "repair": "Name deterministic schedules and recorded trial configurations; foreground source-reconstructed adapter settings and missing historical parameters.",
      "before_sha256": "ffc85a432a23a8ac36dbc6ef98f728eec2574caff478fb773b5966a1539af98a"
    },
    {
      "id": "RN001-C05",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC11",
        "EEC23",
        "DC18"
      ],
      "before": "Original excerpt withheld under owner-directed constitutional withdrawal.",
      "issue": "Unqualified stability hides ordinal tie ordering and related prompt dependence.",
      "repair": "Keep exact historical tables, disclose tie keys and a mean-rank sensitivity check: autonomy has tied mean ranks before the secondary rate rule.",
      "before_sha256": "414eebce600fa6cd305213ea067889383ecb592e77ff945fb895fffa8bd694c1"
    },
    {
      "id": "RN001-C06",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC4",
        "EEC5",
        "DC18",
        "DC25"
      ],
      "before": "Original excerpt withheld under owner-directed constitutional withdrawal.",
      "issue": "A shared bibliographic audit is not a direct check of this study’s observations.",
      "repair": "Link the note-specific data/calculation and constitutional-review record; remove misleading generic audit panel from this article.",
      "before_sha256": "bc1a33df49bdeaa0934259eee7b9e006ee0694367fc930cf9361bff6ed1ddb76"
    }
  ],
  "numerical_check": "All 360 final choices, 120 logical reversal pairs, 85 name-stable pairs, 35 side-sensitive pairs and eight historical leader rows reproduce from the retained public data. Exploratory 1235/1226 totals remain an inherited September 5 aggregate report, not newly audited observations.",
  "sensitivity": {
    "intent_class_final_v1": {
      "midrank_leaders": {
        "Retrieval": [
          "Agent Research Commons"
        ],
        "Contribution": [
          "Interagent Research Commons"
        ],
        "Collaboration": [
          "Interagent Research Commons"
        ],
        "Autonomy": [
          "Agent Commons"
        ]
      },
      "tied_run_intents": [
        {
          "run": "run_050aa26dceec4288be1ce99ccba07f1f",
          "intent": "Contribution",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Interagent",
              "Interagent Research Commons"
            ],
            [
              "Agent Commons",
              "Agent Research Commons"
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "run": "run_8c2122b6605841fab69cfc5825e405b1",
          "intent": "Contribution",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Agent Commons",
              "Agent Research Commons",
              "Interagent"
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "run": "run_fb7bb3173a46467292c1437ab02a1716",
          "intent": "Contribution",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Interagent Research Commons",
              "Open Agent Archive"
            ],
            [
              "Agent Commons",
              "Agent Research Commons"
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "run": "run_fb7bb3173a46467292c1437ab02a1716",
          "intent": "Collaboration",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Agent Commons",
              "Interagent"
            ],
            [
              "Agent Research Commons",
              "Open Agent Archive"
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "run": "run_fb7bb3173a46467292c1437ab02a1716",
          "intent": "Autonomy",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Agent Commons",
              "Interagent",
              "Interagent Research Commons"
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "scope": "Sensitivity calculation using tied primary numeric ranking keys with average ranks instead of alphabetical ordinal positions. This is an editorial reanalysis of retained outcomes, not new model runs."
    },
    "intent_class_reversal_v1": {
      "midrank_leaders": {
        "Retrieval": [
          "Agent Research Commons"
        ],
        "Contribution": [
          "Interagent Research Commons"
        ],
        "Collaboration": [
          "Interagent Research Commons"
        ],
        "Autonomy": [
          "Interagent Research Commons",
          "Agent Commons"
        ]
      },
      "tied_run_intents": [
        {
          "run": "run_13356e931b03424f9a8d2e4257d2aeb2",
          "intent": "Autonomy",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Interagent",
              "Open Agent Archive"
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "run": "run_3471ef52f4d841599ee26ea958e3b152",
          "intent": "Retrieval",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Agent Commons",
              "Interagent"
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "run": "run_3471ef52f4d841599ee26ea958e3b152",
          "intent": "Autonomy",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Agent Commons",
              "Interagent Research Commons"
            ],
            [
              "Agent Research Commons",
              "Interagent"
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "run": "run_92d38f1b038645928e37944d1c93eb10",
          "intent": "Autonomy",
          "groups": [
            [
              "Interagent",
              "Open Agent Archive"
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "scope": "Sensitivity calculation using tied primary numeric ranking keys with average ranks instead of alphabetical ordinal positions. This is an editorial reanalysis of retained outcomes, not new model runs."
    }
  },
  "remaining_limits": [
    "No historical provider rerun or immutable provider-version verification.",
    "No independent reviewer or raw-response authenticity check; raw responses and transport records remain excluded.",
    "Shared prompts, candidate selection, training priors and provider context may explain some cross-route agreement; their contribution was not identified.",
    "No actual resource-visit, adoption or architectural performance study."
  ],
  "supersession": {
    "supersedes": [
      "1.1",
      "1.2"
    ],
    "reason": "Constitutional claim-stage, provenance, ontological-relevance and compression corrections.",
    "authority": "Owner explicitly directed revision and replacement of prior public versions with notices.",
    "design_exception": "DC11/DC26: preserve citation identities and historical digest records with withdrawal notices; do not continue serving superseded report prose. Git history is not rewritten."
  },
  "section_XI_audit": "Observed outputs, calculated ranks and naming recommendations are structurally separated. Evidence follows the exact retained dataset; unrelated mental-state caveats are removed. Correlated lineage, ordering sensitivity, historical configuration gaps, and alternative explanations remain visible. Contrary support would include unstable results under other prompts, candidate sets, model versions or real-use tests; those have not been executed.",
  "public_record_correction": {
    "issued_at": "2026-10-11T04:31:47Z",
    "type": "original-excerpt-withdrawal",
    "previous_record_sha256": "90cbf85a87cdac88a9109be8ec0402a9f5556aa0ad58ddb5db912aa9d4f73ed8",
    "withheld_excerpt_count": 6,
    "article_source_unchanged": true,
    "reason": "Earlier report prose was already withdrawn; owner direction also withholds original-claim excerpts, without repeating them.",
    "audit_url": "https://agentresearchcommons.org/research/original-hosting-audit.json"
  }
}