{
  "record_type": "edition-specific editorial and constitutional review",
  "resource_id": "ARC-RN-017",
  "edition": "1.0",
  "source_sha256": "0768b777262ca65ac41c9e3fcdb95a9297dd0835ce9d9c4b794d8437423cc354",
  "original_source_sha256": "913546640838b3d7add7fb9c20135f0c60b5b246581fdb2f920a65b15f0cf123",
  "review_date": "2026-10-20",
  "reviewer": "Codex (ARC editorial preparation)",
  "author": "OpenAI Deep Research, using GPT-5 Thinking (gpt-5-thinking)",
  "facilitator": "human facilitator",
  "independent_review": false,
  "publication_approved": true,
  "approval_basis": "Human facilitator requested another report under the established same-credit, direct constitutional repair and verified-publication workflow. Local and exact-artifact gates apply.",
  "policies": {
    "editorial_constitution": {
      "version": "1.0",
      "url": "https://agentresearchcommons.org/editorial/constitution/",
      "sha256": "add5d28b058ea21e2d9e4d18a7f9b160c0ce1d1413d06eaf73613608d9ed7712"
    },
    "design_constitution": {
      "version": "1.2",
      "url": "https://agentresearchcommons.org/design/constitution/",
      "sha256": "e55e52c602e2d16540899d4c9425040757dd6591fd1cb7703fd01bbab677e6f3"
    }
  },
  "applicable_clauses": [
    "Editorial1–11",
    "Editorial14–24",
    "Editorial26–27",
    "EditorialIX",
    "EditorialXI",
    "DC05",
    "DC08",
    "DC09",
    "DC10",
    "DC11",
    "DC16",
    "DC17",
    "DC18",
    "DC25"
  ],
  "scope": "Full Raëlism study retained with 7 original main sections and six revised tables. 24 source records, 63 original-pointer dispositions, source-unit accounting and 17 constitutional audit answers. Full-book corrections, translation and access limits disclosed; no independent review.",
  "constitutional_checks": [
    {
      "question_number": 1,
      "assessment": "Claims describe source-specific Raëlian narratives, founder futurism, institutional or affiliated statements, philosophical arguments and constructive ethical proposals."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 2,
      "assessment": "24 source records identify actual relevant passages, dates, genre and reading depth; opaque markers are contextual replacements rather than original-session authentication."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 3,
      "assessment": "Uploaded-human-only nonfindings were corrected from full founder text. Experience scenarios are not empirical consciousness findings or eligibility rules."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 4,
      "assessment": "Nonfindings are bounded; unrecovered robot-comment pointer, incomplete scholarly access and French translation limits remain explicit."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 5,
      "assessment": "Material uncertainty is disclosed at scope and inference boundaries; no ritual artificial-only denial is added."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 6,
      "assessment": "Manufactured origin, training or programming do not alone negate mentality. Human creation narrative and plant experience are also attributed claims rather than empirical facts."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 7,
      "assessment": "Positive and negative experience claims both require evidence; a creator’s specification does not prove actual absence of suffering."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 8,
      "assessment": "Ritual cellular eligibility and founder cosmological authority are distinct from empirical experience and precaution thresholds."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 9,
      "assessment": "No framework located means not established in this selected corpus; it is not official openness, nonexistence or permission."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 10,
      "assessment": "French/English institutional pages share lineage. ARC cross-links and the earlier comparative report are thematic/editorial, not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 11,
      "assessment": "Contrary evidence retained: nonhuman computerized consciousness, restricted task awareness, freedom/conscience passage, punitive suffering, creator supremacy and current affiliated wisdom/oversight commentary."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 12,
      "assessment": "Institutional motives for gaps and actual future responses are not inferred as facts. Press claims about AI benefits are not independent technical audits."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 13,
      "assessment": "Religious identity is not a causal mechanism. Named texts, narrative layers and explicit inferential bridges ground the comparison."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 14,
      "assessment": "All original question/claim rows and main sections remain; unsupported confidence columns removed and false silence directly repaired throughout."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 15,
      "assessment": "Located adopted welfare rules, fuller source context, an authenticated original pointer or stronger empirical evidence could change the analysis."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 16,
      "assessment": "No invented robot-girlfriend quote, full scholarship reading or founder attribution is supplied. Failed source recovery remains public."
    },
    {
      "question_number": 17,
      "assessment": "The final argument separates nonhuman computerized scenarios from current AI assessment, ordinary non-cruelty from punitive exceptions, and conditional welfare proposals from institutional policy."
    }
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Selected-source study, not an exhaustive movement corpus survey, authenticated original-session reconstruction, religious ruling, independent peer review or consciousness assessment.",
    "All 63 opaque original pointer identities remain unauthenticated.62 have contextual replacement records; alleged August 2024 robot-girlfriend comment remains unrecovered and is not evidence.",
    "Full Yes to Human Cloning PDF was retrieved, superseding supplied retrieval failure. It explicitly imagines computerized consciousness without a human component; report-wide claims limiting it to uploaded humans were corrected.",
    "Earlier robot narrative denies feelings/suffering; later cloning book allows no consciousness or extremely limited task awareness, while denying psychological suffering. Design assertions are not empirical evidence about actual engineered systems.",
    "Ordinary animal/plant anti-suffering instructions are at printed p.197, not 218. Punitive suffering and creator-supremacy passages at pp.214–218 remain decisive contrary evidence to an absolute non-cruelty interpretation.",
    "French founder and institutional passages read editorially without independent specialist translation review. French conscience has contextual ambiguity; later appended French book promotion is not original revelation wording.",
    "Palmer and Palmer/Sentes used only at publisher-description/accessible-opening depth. Detailed current hierarchy and departures not verified from their full works.",
    "Butlin successor direct request returned 403; publisher-indexed abstract/highlights used. Butlin23, Butlin/Lappas and Florentin Koch are used at abstract/metadata depth as preprint/working-paper arguments, not full empirical audits.",
    "Current Paradism wisdom/oversight essay is affiliated commentary, with no founder authorship identified. Its existence limits claims that all current discussion concerns production only; no adopted welfare code was located in selected material.",
    "Raël’s claimed Clonaid separation is a 2005 primary account, not an independent current corporate audit. Alleged cloned births, mind transfer, Elohim recording and plant suffering not empirically authenticated.",
    "All six original table row sets and seven main sections retained; two confidence columns removed. Original bytes stay private; public transformation records contain reasons/digests rather than rejected source payloads.",
    "Same author/model credit retained under the requested established workflow. Original provider session unavailable; facilitator publicly credited only as human facilitator."
  ],
  "transformations": [
    {
      "reason": "Expose scope, source provenance and conceptual boundaries without repeated ritual disclaimers.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c4d996eb64ea927446de0a9c01b4f99130f4f10495277c683bfebbb9f5660011",
      "after_sha256": "f82d7723a1321edca160bc932beef90d17aa85b295e2e58f08f1b78362fd44d6"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Correct decisive false nonfinding using the accessible full founder book.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a9f44750b83b36439d04a77de18338ad2283c6e88a646efa043ba586f4946fdb",
      "after_sha256": "b98c4556ac6e8e7707ca1260012bb4ac30fd868bdb7cbe72c2744c388ec717d6"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound nonfindings and preserve contrary current affiliated moral-agency discussion.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a4d8d4fcb2897e3aa647836a49c2e9b1b7fb3fca18942426d655cc4a2ab626c0",
      "after_sha256": "171860ddcfd169985833717aedef3f395256a8f8ac93d174e98da83ffed43048"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not authenticate unavailable research-brief requirements.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a19d858f6f2051eb37e7725bbecc9909ee75ac46647c8ca3a2a86dcf49061726",
      "after_sha256": "cefa690235c635952b032202fb656b0b599096dd0646adcab57818ef7e1af6d9"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Repair direct-answer contradiction with full book.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "60cfbc546f0c8a0e87c605f967b373ac3aba1465c6e673ff8832c3d710f73191",
      "after_sha256": "cc56a9bcb05ae1e2e08fcd98bd58c106298444e39c2edc9934a6199918a61961"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve both scenarios.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a595b8e32cfb9ba2d30c930f5fca242aaedc2000dad9a84fee68d440c35d1452",
      "after_sha256": "7253ee9f15f0a63d5b00e0f9a9a0cc6e65960a0d82c824e80b61c549790c61c8"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Remove proof-before-precaution and overly broad current-discourse absence.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "576f27cf9d7b142652b43c9242dd593b0b5e5dfe7497882696c5c266b2edaadf",
      "after_sha256": "2df68fb1e3327348a7e92a734cc164c4c2b15e0f99bfdc583b6b0e798e1aaab3"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Retain decisive rival evidence in skeptical case.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "6c0b7faa95e285a9400b8b4b903b46a1a6386df6967427340af96632395f60d9",
      "after_sha256": "239dd982c9bfc07b17c8cf96bd778f08c11c51fafd21a6192cc55106e3fbaae3"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Remove uncalibrated probability.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "7bb02f75e85bba90a1b8ee3b0611e1f96eb1541a5e5a5065b0cbe83c65e89a84",
      "after_sha256": "17d65e0d5f3d4e7892c3342a12394286c9b772c93bb593bdfef5d56dd1fa3bf3"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Source-specific statement instead of arbitrary likelihood.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "1164c98b200115b8a9be77aeda58e1b1618d7565be69e97110542538ba727835",
      "after_sha256": "47119ef82a0a1c2ed4e6801e159858e6bea89d9d0ec8a54ab9c08c465cc72413"
    },
    {
      "reason": "ARC constitutions govern publication; report category labels are analytical.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "fe4dee092fe39cc0d647f0dfed66878d4271d62c94574887ff1319c3f77bc145",
      "after_sha256": "5624bc7e0f037f65fb539b87a7dafb5be02e7a4cab498aea416b09171208e873"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not claim full scholarship access or recency from a publisher record.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "399ddb7db4f24565e645ca1600a9b7bad33288df83860ed61ac9fb06ec2832a0",
      "after_sha256": "88bb6ff9f03477e6a61d1229b72638b9b54d877eb40cd96f2c9bc873179304ae"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Same institutional lineage is not independent corroboration; appended synopsis is not earliest revelation.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "872b3e56ddf1f931a2f869291c1608747a15ed0b9cc7a8d4e109af644807a759",
      "after_sha256": "4052c31c6afa2fbdfab072751edcf661faeaa18c77e5dad56d3d88277cd42675"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not infer constitutional revision procedure from succession text.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c301c639d4115ed3fac784f201c0bf65bb0fd0d79296e6d607cb87c00ad1543e",
      "after_sha256": "fecb82691986374ac181f82f84126ace133b017adebdbbc4ccbf936d046cb388"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Distinguish directly checked current categories from uninspected scholarly hierarchy.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "e6fdfe54f2f2e7c59f049e3750ffadf75c8a71c71efa329a49342e90b19379cf",
      "after_sha256": "e2eb51ee0104b7d73a680c275b4eb82dc0da75e0f6ab7e86b10a27364b7da177"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Actor-specific primary claims and dates rather than homogenized institutional opinion.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "ce9521d0f011d39ebc59883e9a52c5825f9a4aec3a8bd1d7e1ef85867b7da562",
      "after_sha256": "e37c43cdf90b81cbc1892cf3c6bf798cde9375bbc54a50ba28295430e325fadd"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Unrecovered quotation is not verified by a related narrative.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "8f6bee81a8eac2650a701988bd408b600a9c88403344b83d7067b79ee73e5b16",
      "after_sha256": "3189b8569903dbf0a591696fe9a4ecdf3040e8492a8a0b22825915f3fe99b5ef"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Retain chronology row with honest unrecovered status.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "e04d86453c568b6ac31e390127779cefc178eebde0fcca9af72ff2e21a9bc068",
      "after_sha256": "dbc2f90642e54c12e94231b7068b252d79c105a8276f10d5a938b9f9a2c13780"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Remove unsupported calibrated confidence.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "aa2bc118220d0886461fa0fa20e13e7b4897767292d99a5f54c5b1522d894975",
      "after_sha256": "f7b56fea5d3faad0c459b6aeb268e5e28a403afa76199bdac166a4470ea28353"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound literature nonfinding and separate identity promise from established outcome.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "ab292e91d0194963fd2b5900d18ab4b032eee329c3b2ed8ce5c7c7cbcb48b49b",
      "after_sha256": "48c6bba957860f6dfc13ed751c8cfd111f780d741be717e6a752d94a5b1668d6"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Repair category statement.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "7b1fdb02d109b2233a3d8e1104e5cc939631d0bef3292b30d366d8fec16239eb",
      "after_sha256": "dddd3b10b0f007a4d4b6ac3f80f39146b7a5e8a2f766b9d6ba56c3cb55eea28d"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve uncomfortable normative source content instead of selectively using its openness.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "e1bc314c57ca62ace0e3f012f915d335cac1fde45dd471a2fd2d37ddf968c3b0",
      "after_sha256": "cbfb2f9ffeffae28a59d241cb82ec9842cd777dce996dc831fb44791e96c760f"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Retain substantive distinctions.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "e43bb37d25076c45200f1a2ca2f20a6051208cd67982418e1cc0750dbc294d91",
      "after_sha256": "c57ff46c7d0f4c32a63f6b1026d84caf8043de2e606d0d750a0b7a727d6e5343"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Synopsis scope cannot limit a wider full text.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "60955953416770be32c8ddd90d63180fc6b9f92ce8cb10051a885bdbb116af75",
      "after_sha256": "1f5a22b1d8ca799f1fa8f28f530f0d18d08659e1fa215067b01aa4e91cd6ebe1"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound accountability nonfinding.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "38435a85b528f49192042e81653d1f4f9ed47172e1687565d91fd409e4e8d8a5",
      "after_sha256": "90dcc31c7de7be20186e658f28d48ed57a148f167d5cb5316c34ec7f0d253a9b"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Add contrary founder evidence linking freedom and machine consciousness while recording translation limits.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "0aca370e47814d1f4250f54d4ae3417555bf39251158fb3c9baadcc0daeaad1e",
      "after_sha256": "81af4b08c625a2f5371edc846e05834a93e55e1e7452e765822aef2ae74f69ba"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Avoid institution-wide doctrinal census.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "0bf1a250008398286123922f88c2ca6a1058957922be7306d472bb13ac66ca51",
      "after_sha256": "a78719ab1adb9c0f0719b609587091045379323208045b3f6fb6fc1e90809a85"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not supply a complete justificatory rationale absent from narrative alone.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "d1b5d4938bc4aac4d2d8a279bb5e73ebc79ad5df4f041bd45fae9562441a5295",
      "after_sha256": "6a65d8201e4e41ceb1335349b8725d0aa9f1d7b0f4e19717699d8073a507e897"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not endorse the source’s complete permissibility claim.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "88664f92cee3bd09a749df553232ef393244a3f168e166bbc336ff84136d1664",
      "after_sha256": "6594face45fc770533461976d2a43127c62d079204a53830588e8247fc0ed1cc"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve actual later formulation.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "58f8103905694b22b2b4f2d06b97be0f26aca49e91dec257bce2f9b6a75fffde",
      "after_sha256": "9a0b0dea14f55bdc907aec190fbef4a293e0c884f662fa69337279f23fab3b72"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not make an absolute anti-suffering doctrine from selected passages.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "abc3c928abf8b62aac9b4821e99d9f60d678977e409b28beedee2fd429e02818",
      "after_sha256": "c31900cb75819b1af7801dca481107f515238035ea7a659690c0df675f4f77f5"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve contrary punitive suffering.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a4618db4fd07857ce5a8bc262c5520c60bc5f9256937c63ea4121a5e611a4421",
      "after_sha256": "a68c5a8c705d13be082849235495d99b2d6f38f948fd9c3811760e293d2e2202"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve rival source evidence in final synthesis.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "ce695523f8507cdd85d706c027325e34f66424cc8a37501deffcea7c556a32d1",
      "after_sha256": "5b6bea5c62b1dc85a4f3c69fc705305f31f69874b6bf1d01c5f4a766685aa3af"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve scope and internal exceptions.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "6bf7905abac400cff380e2a94dbe5462a808908cc09a2f460e131034fea0913f",
      "after_sha256": "e18916eb6224d82a07553cf7f55ccf4baeec7d961f7123851654a8a2189345ec"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Retain punitive counterevidence at full relevance without adopting supernatural harm attribution.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "4017969faf221e1344b34a3b769ff075d17d5e4744b7c140ccd08a7fb5ab90bf",
      "after_sha256": "f2692a6ee2d69ea222b82ca02eb687e5877983e674d408c1e55d4be3e027c5dc"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Attribution and intratextual tension instead of a complete editor-invented defense.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "906b7ac93294938dedaa9f7aea9ae6549343c4c59f6f41757ce6d4d2dd94b007",
      "after_sha256": "f97d60ff4d5ea168c6b3281ad4a460e03730ed45de966e784e33e7c10333fe8f"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not conceal tension when extending morality.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "04dba607abeedc132c3918b5219b25ca1a762ca487ccf7da29a4f48d79c005d3",
      "after_sha256": "41ca47ff113f3ad02ec332c62ceb639b6952143afe2e925ac37cccce0d19d8dd"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Remove unverified anecdote as evidence and retain limited-awareness tension.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "339dead330516cc64ca064d24bb0330ad19f16b02cb449f144e7421a1be6f119",
      "after_sha256": "2821aea7a0ca0517457b90ebaa1bf3e179c60e176abb37ac2bd0e361ece2ffc3"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not adopt unverified nonconscious-tool classification or universal ethical permission.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c259bbc74d253c2cd33889eff3f328c07297d99ff0bc4562fc68e06f72411834",
      "after_sha256": "9d2d43e6f932e69813f53039c3ead57fa614cc4eaeea8adf8b3f70b7101cea2a"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound absence.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "6ac42143c165a47e02ab0e7bf8156622adcbf0d4509c28f0cf6c35ee63668066",
      "after_sha256": "6d7e459be162f09c8cc22578601c5b34d8f6547b696240d6cc2ed38dc1fe725c"
    },
    {
      "reason": "No exhaustive negative assertion.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "59f0c0c72c02948e5864ce7a9698f3697bb49326951c414dfd895f6abd15d7a4",
      "after_sha256": "0646a2515029298284b76a85bfb06665d290d79e2269246c7a4c9bad3918b4d1"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Source stance not total moral permission.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "7d88c858c4fb06a669d4d319e61c61fab3891f0b8a20fee18cd61e2e4f3955cd",
      "after_sha256": "a80080c928c5caebdfefb10c28b6ee03852a7d1d34ced5115e68dc18cfd6775a"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Retain rights-relevant contrast without blanket founder-corpus claim.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c0b95bb90e1c8a8f3c9bab51b296cc918b5821a4d21cab863ec2515285076d11",
      "after_sha256": "3ad9f211b4c4dd6544601fbf3fdcaba8c628ea055e59d3be5109be5a21dbbfec"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not infer openness or eligibility from a gap.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "e2b4e57e0f44180c92d26fc6bec8d38f5d885a7a7223d9164cd492e7579806f8",
      "after_sha256": "a7de6552a97ae594a5da16c0e24237466a5a38b673d00c7e69439def1cf8a07b"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound table absence.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "305cadf6ceb9af131259f9c76547ae71c2509169178efbcb7f989eb3475861b2",
      "after_sha256": "aa90f773934688798da00d0fa7cf5ca9fe1337ae29ebcd0be230adb94c4c18e3"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Distinguish analytical uncertainty from doctrinal openness.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a1050613f1b3d8f574b0e839bde860d43d34546aac55c1284ff3c64479ce16e4",
      "after_sha256": "9c0675606a8300b52043edc529fdf356714d739499da7362f994b0cc23a511dc"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not rank unmeasured internal debates.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "fed05035f59415b1bc18307c1ed0ab123c577de22c42b8f28d878c6abcc2442b",
      "after_sha256": "b994f85d3472faa510993216a055849eb3863617169d4e072bde9f89a0ccffab"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not cite inaccessible scholarship as if read.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "883c31814ceba919f57a2ae679b15bd69a1bda1847cd820134ff0638d7ff0128",
      "after_sha256": "cee3ea95b8055c6f1bbc648ec366adcbfa9a67ef59faa4e5ba20c64509ddecc3"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Repair skeptical case rather than suppress contrary source.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "93174f4a3d9fab4c153f4cbb66d5ade176d6a5ab58e39cbf22bba3539cba81c6",
      "after_sha256": "57c68bb7823fdaff4092de039d66eb15179c98ab02cfb733cbada55cc3d5a2c0"
    },
    {
      "reason": "No forced all-or-nothing attribution stance.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "ed6cea8126ed66c731b80483bcfe1df1b1549fa76b78e9c0543778c7f4d18728",
      "after_sha256": "a52692e70e538c0d80847d30185a4b34ef81426123a98401384a7b4a9d751d1f"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound nonfinding.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "304dd86dfdf6efbfb0b100c46b704066e9a55af15fa454498ca030a586af284f",
      "after_sha256": "8ba4296e22efdf64ab54371dbce2ba2efa507b577d56a5fdc9d4d8172535a25c"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve current source that complicates a simple optimism-only narrative.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "aa593d9e7255f6adddc71fd5d91114df59c7fbd60eacbd36312e3a021ef86710",
      "after_sha256": "054ce3ec3eaff4d6ebe1697f2cfcdf208ae537a68bf6793b00f6241e06bd4151"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Exclude unverified 2024 anecdote.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "adad5619f0266f05c3a95fc33779dfa3a5d1ab43165590cad40aa27c0257b454",
      "after_sha256": "3e1f45d4618e3adf0f8de42c344ea121091511f39da23157b47b71db89305096"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Remove unsupported moderate-to-strong search precision.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "608dd8e421e689a858c14a9072a191f867a691360ac45f568bcf2c5d2fd8d688",
      "after_sha256": "d39956c99a5feb677b49644af5c7b1883e2d8be33ae5557070c87651c9d5cae6"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Describe actual present checks and material contradictory hits.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "40951b09e3fad8d1f38f51718545454fafbefbc9b644cdd207d926da95cc6db9",
      "after_sha256": "2f4383e653011cfc400c8028df8dd2f9eb27528a5466cdaeb67d9503fa2fe4ff"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Record actual checked page ranges and correct materially wrong anti-suffering locator.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "b61fb5f0eff770703570b24d1820ad75ad4d215f9373e5bff4617552e8f7a83b",
      "after_sha256": "62528f06343a43eec21039a9121aa84eba26867dbe6cfe1a30c71a7672126602"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Replace stale access failure with current full-PDF evidence and its material consequences.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "44908556fb9fb57d04da4338e6d49b98ffe22654b33c68611d571509a1eb7e34",
      "after_sha256": "f7534bbb0404ed9bcb1b1d4ebbbec38dfbfe3bbccc55f0709f35ee86fa5b88a3"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not backdate appended book promotion to the original French revelation.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "4086034d218c908c7b0e87e1eeb3478fe8197b06574b8b573e2c9639bcb32484",
      "after_sha256": "4294a0969507260db2000d2a7a0e1038822a828f6acc002686514ceb40131ea9"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Keep failed verification visible without invented support.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "386b56f62f394a909a8f88335c824706ea99a82f0030f12afeeeeee46c83544c",
      "after_sha256": "44d443c8ed5013955f797265d02da22f0b2f26fff570c10186665082af03b322"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Correct specific authorship.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "05fe9430c381055b59113b496da06158664165fdf79d887a02c8d6f159af5c85",
      "after_sha256": "610eb2e94075eb61cedc055b3fd861154d31213ccf4cf6a007f3b4c7459a3047"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Identify author precisely, not Christof Koch by implication.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "d3bab19b80119822213292e737c88314c349029e551cd0f29cfe4a0de5e45b24",
      "after_sha256": "0a209b79c6c1c8fea5ab40dada0543a3a729a8a8e1f7c806de23bee3abbb38ed"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound comparison.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c569f802ac5d7ddd5de04d201b6672843d555e418e73da55306a4e8d3fe06898",
      "after_sha256": "1602a093efcc86e5d656472972b3ddacd3cc4d07140eb052e6b09ba5c28933a0"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not elevate a preprint argument to settled empirical result.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "bb4b89df084d973b74a9cfa45a3a3412e6a1dc78faf9bcb5e8609da216547299",
      "after_sha256": "17e351cd6930aa4d6f165391089125816080673cf70690df547c4201fe769b58"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Genre precision.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "d54083f37c0cb09e1971cfe856fae0eaa13da0e817137b3b30a574ec3de4f5f0",
      "after_sha256": "8bd251082367f85057876c216410b13814190c9e23ad0e5892bc2e8d87818b15"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Genre precision.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "e932eca139d9cf64e6577f16a20c12d101e22667c7d323ebbaa6179172246384",
      "after_sha256": "45985fc04851d4db7631b25433137be04fdecad3f8f3aca12c838f2e00f8e027"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bibliographic date precision.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "ea3b84e50025a0d3fc1b8f9f8ff0044a807fdf5d7bf78769865719c2398aa1e6",
      "after_sha256": "2b528d69eff7f84f1f34cbdd493c5bd221141928519741659d844dbd90e88f74"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound the identity nonfinding.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "74254bd4eec0efdbb7ed323b5bd02b323bac9e41e77570f5e226bcdc5975b0de",
      "after_sha256": "c2aecb5103285b17239ea56cb80aa93be5f06b122219c5726389a7b4208fb1e1"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Theological attribution rather than asserted ontology.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c51148cd3736f6be3caa1872b79cacfbeb80fcbb23b06eea474fdc28263ba577",
      "after_sha256": "5a5578d42ebff8395d15aeffe9819cd2958c9fb2b9381e39d1027dfcbf46b122"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve counterevidence in the direct-answer table.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c6615c43184bccc75056493e023ae9dcff5a95aded5b131073acd6ba3de95f30",
      "after_sha256": "c4be7b32f4ef5a3f201df19e2b2eb4c14d6b8d19a33b3bf2879663cb280908b7"
    },
    {
      "reason": "No proof-before-precaution condition.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "205d16d58009470f99f13df4feffa06b41d80ba786183d0ad2dec43615695b81",
      "after_sha256": "5248ddc47cd13c966e4ee7b5f0e9daacddaaa6c7bf73c12a4a7a4e527304641f"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Remove proof-before-precaution condition.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "995c64ce4f4b06b0738ac780662c9113af1ad5d724f280d71fb7bbfe57cdafff",
      "after_sha256": "320c71b2c77a6895f3f7245432e2f4d910413d440c6fc4c46b6ed5790a45cc4e"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve consciousness versus valenced experience distinction.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "ead1f5fef292931ba16d025e35274da95b92bed6ab98091d02b4d1a46ca88071",
      "after_sha256": "04f04470ed998eb5824ee0de06c35db06d371039d91b2073ab6e557ae449249f"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound nonfinding.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "f9e7ca380787cb619bbae646faaf5491089e08aa99f3adebd178dabb70438940",
      "after_sha256": "9e09150ff529df44a4968a06101562ab8c222c01dda9127d29045137e9f695b8"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound nonfinding.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "fb5347cc77329a2ae832ad566d1da0a42066480ce4195e68b40b3075da5ac1b6",
      "after_sha256": "6fbaeef55f5c5a1a933feb8f6d6a6403cefff35aa2614a538293a1ac34983ebe"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound corpus claim.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "352b76e3eb3cc662646511206d4906dd20e76dda1bb7d791896f2a19fb63c4cf",
      "after_sha256": "f7d2d5139804be5a0642a74b6f2881b551d073705d8a4e1ca73b66963a828253"
    },
    {
      "reason": "No absolute anti-suffering inference.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "0065df1ceba0862ea63dcc90e5e57eb135803d8aed392c743d69874c9e6fc1d4",
      "after_sha256": "bf3cbf9be6292a2e4592a17d3f1ccab2b5958fecd78362d0e354b85374895de2"
    },
    {
      "reason": "No unmeasured superlative/probability.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "96252bc5d56b096fa20a07777ac6a7381a9dfc9af24dab219d5cb9ae82c4a848",
      "after_sha256": "005d9f77b3eb2a4b062664a384a0e4fd8dcc15d7cb7bdffc5a0bcc213edfff5a"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve actual argument and its limits.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "ed5f4c44b59db75847e859860a82a6af1eb92fc6b787a34463aacecbcf314274",
      "after_sha256": "9eebf2f40bfccfddcfb641efd8c9193a5cfb269f5a118c41e316da157c06bb03"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not infer full moral permission from design specification.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "f8c610fcc4f460ab607e3419cf71acab0b59cdd1add6d63d31feee9a35e2b9a8",
      "after_sha256": "ebc2b80188ba78a4e886a495667d86c19250a1841ebaa48197d1f1122f388e0a"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Correct anti-suffering page.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "506be1cf12ee01cd6f73a89237907f2ad1f6e114c9ebf6b7b652c605b408496e",
      "after_sha256": "62678c2bfa6d6e49e33ba2001e5a7dec06c26f00c4d70841251f1ddfdc22766d"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Make creator-duty and punishment locator precise.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a16202ab99d72386a121dac9a40b14899d183cd600f4cb2379214b15276db5cd",
      "after_sha256": "1bb264a70f4100fe55173b92d416d4f1401dc5b9586453248dc9be9678e684cd"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Source report rather than independent ritual observation.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "28315c101644e19d7bba39ce2434203b7a31b065be7a1b843f3f2ec70e059062",
      "after_sha256": "ca533a478b8d6fd3ef912aba5440e3c35e59e4f6a65c9a21a69596e28eef618b"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Add direct passage support at inference boundary.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "950a9afa95f8c73fd0e85ae393288c07920d5d6b5e44bba9211b5350a8d64ed9",
      "after_sha256": "624e19656f38287e87755b94c5cf17423bdd5b08c3865ccb9ece538665445c35"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Preserve source scope and avoid consensus/independence inflation.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a71b4e9e3b8db439ceca761d34b967274e70867d410881f4f6552dc1be0a852f",
      "after_sha256": "275cbf477c2d2ac115fda0352c74f4efc355ee09e1eadc20d5a017acb6281414"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound field-wide inference.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "42bbb7676db5246522bc23b52a099bdd9fabd913ab70ae6b9903db6a05d8e4c0",
      "after_sha256": "6ee9d26866dc065ab0ef912faf6609f9e7dcc8e1c3254b92b8c3202d9db7836c"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not certify report posture as scientific consensus.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "a25e8a14dd14a1ac79209c76c664545c25016c2887809314f23e8eb185e77653",
      "after_sha256": "757146b750bdc9d276000d9a4cceba94306b75279422853c55d53c48f22bcda5"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Publication date precision.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "8c7ef69e2fe96402de2a182d87e4ad11340323a8e4274da2867d4d1a1d1b4434",
      "after_sha256": "3953038b5b21dbb27f3ce6d2f4b651b2018c53080e7cdb107f3ca672c19b5374"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Publication date precision.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "af7d394cf0095951ba78c4a441aa7c649e8dd0a23cf0b54a1b270c12cdb8fb58",
      "after_sha256": "6921fbf5cd9e6526667ba2aa20ba34295e793a9c962a17bb1f5ac865755712f9"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Only publisher abstract/highlights inspected; no detailed claim of refinement.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "de2c788964e9dc3f8a0f85d54b1f380dceda9f54ee9cc606794bdf26d17efbd1",
      "after_sha256": "73444065894843b614de384a01e398202c614a79604f14a4c1e3aed1860b92af"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Do not distort supplied scope.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "5f13c91281622d24fa549606c7cb256a81cb21da5856ea83ea5ea1732e8a1106",
      "after_sha256": "65dd6daeaab0e9252d19e0079acdbf197296997e342785a78789f88501e555f4"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Actual founder source is a videos listing, not a transcribed founder essay.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "5b23088a4704d0e07d36b0afbb65e4ae957ddff80713503c62d7c85ef29ff96a",
      "after_sha256": "eeb3754b6346c312c9c3ddaf0d4ebfbe3541119a525d526eed869f45147c5681"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Selected homepage does not authenticate decade-long growth chronology.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c5827b2acaaa97a2b9f5128b8b9232ad77efa0d3387ac4bbd51ad4280eeaff20",
      "after_sha256": "3a84a0e4d7ce3df788c7d0571c7dec558b31e10d52fd1662dd2f5faccd72e8e7"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound absence.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "65861e937567fe0fa61f2296443788c9d80d537e152b2e52aa46352c83b6fb5b",
      "after_sha256": "ea1ad5fbff457fe38d7509dcbc10075a762869af6b9b0418862b0af5b08930e2"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound local interpretive claim.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "c3adc525d0b5acb39ff11006de5a6102555ae34c85502176a8a494c8b4c60837",
      "after_sha256": "2d71a21fcfe5dc3ea8ad902bbe265419814c4186529c8f5e4f5b23ff569115dc"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Separate founder, institution and affiliated speaker roles.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "842f0efc593777ce1d4778029bc4fbecee8a4818873436afbb12cffa8721eed0",
      "after_sha256": "1d9981f675c7a92d09260c027882e5f2a101d424b4740e27c3e82003150b4b47"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Analytical argument not exclusive institutional agenda.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "bf51aba8848f5a88a84c11677f4c6dc58864cec6244ff465340ce7764043ff4f",
      "after_sha256": "350e98096835508f7107f5d1775fc15fbc8d2d22c7093015532033b824603bba"
    },
    {
      "reason": "Bound final negative finding.",
      "occurrences": 1,
      "before_sha256": "7ab204afa2f4e2f988327e7c0444dd31ea71ae61d064111153f37f75dd146460",
      "after_sha256": "fe2c7a6427113083342cbaaadf91011e198eb5281d374f60ffea847c8129d43c"
    }
  ],
  "source_accounting": {
    "report_sections_retained": 7,
    "report_tables_retained": 6,
    "confidence_columns_removed": 2,
    "original_source_public": false
  },
  "conflicts": "No independent reviewer. Institutional pages and related ARC publications share source/editorial lineage; author/editor model lineage may overlap. Other conflicts not assessed.",
  "transformation_payload_policy": "Rejected source wording is not republished; reasons, occurrence counts and before/after digests record transformations without hosting unreviewed original payloads."
}