{
  "resource_id": "ARC-REVIEW-001",
  "edition": "1.4",
  "date": "2026-10-04",
  "independent_review": false,
  "responsible_role": "ARC agent-assisted constitutional editorial revision; the ARC site owner authorized publication-history supersession under DC11/DC26",
  "policy_versions": {
    "editorial_epistemic": "1.0",
    "design": "1.1"
  },
  "original_source_sha256": "62a8ccc26c0bab22ef3938e99c73c9eeef4c526255c600a51e19e287f1474ba7",
  "current_source_sha256": "aa906af6a71c8ca43bd43ccfa57f9de078cc685faaa431d3c8e27f12e8b0f987",
  "review_scope": "Complete5987-word submitted essay read with paragraph and eleven endnote mapping; source metadata and historical editions examined. Selected primary source passages/abstracts checked: Bales autonomy assumptions, IJCAI off-switch, UAI interruptibility, Long/Sebo/Sims safety/welfare, Lennon publisher, ICML Xiao final proceedings. Prior bibliographic checks retained as historical, not converted to full claim verification.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "REVIEW001-C01",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC14",
        "EEC15",
        "EEC16",
        "EEC17",
        "EEC19"
      ],
      "before": "Repeated present-tool/future-subject framing",
      "issue": "Repeated ontology caveats defer relevance to hypothetical future and risk turning unassessed status into permission.",
      "repair": "Conditions apply to existing, changed or newly recognized properties; uncertainty assigned to claims/interventions; stipulated absence separated from missing evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "REVIEW001-C02",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC1",
        "EEC13",
        "EEC18",
        "EEC20"
      ],
      "before": "Danger without any consciousness/malice/fear and off-switch implication",
      "issue": "Operational explanation can imply psychological absence and adds unnecessary caveat to opening.",
      "repair": "Lead with objective/interruption behavior; formal premises do not establish absence of other deployed mechanisms."
    },
    {
      "id": "REVIEW001-C03",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC1",
        "EEC3",
        "EEC4",
        "EEC22"
      ],
      "before": "Bales fundamental service orientation",
      "issue": "Omitting mere-servant/no-other-desires condition broadens argued result.",
      "repair": "Restore full stipulated conditions and distinguish revisable service roles, preserving permissive/paternalism rival."
    },
    {
      "id": "REVIEW001-C04",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC4",
        "EEC5",
        "EEC6",
        "EEC11",
        "EEC24",
        "EEC25"
      ],
      "before": "Independent evaluation would reduce risk",
      "issue": "Proposed safeguard efficacy and evidential independence are assumed rather than established.",
      "repair": "Label intended/unvalidated effects; document shared sources/training/incentives, criteria, conflicts, rival tests and evaluator contestability."
    },
    {
      "id": "REVIEW001-C05",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC14",
        "EEC17",
        "EEC19",
        "EEC27"
      ],
      "before": "More than convincing imitation of language",
      "issue": "Imitation prelabels disputed evidence and requires asymmetric authenticity proof.",
      "repair": "Attribute utterances; evaluate claim-specific mechanisms with comparable evidential burdens."
    },
    {
      "id": "REVIEW001-C06",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC1",
        "EEC3",
        "EEC4",
        "EEC5",
        "EEC10"
      ],
      "before": "SSRN note8 and survey-wide principal rationales",
      "issue": "Resolver association remains inaccessible; selected cited policies cannot establish field-wide motives/prevalence.",
      "repair": "Use inspected final ICML proceedings, six authors/pages; bound policy rationales to named documents and distinguish norm argument/source evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "REVIEW001-C07",
      "clauses": [
        "EEC3",
        "EEC5",
        "DC10",
        "DC11",
        "DC18",
        "DC26"
      ],
      "before": "Earlier sources and credits preserved as current",
      "issue": "The ARC site owner authorized supersession in all public formats, while source and metadata credits differed; the publication record did not clearly separate site-governance authority from contributor roles.",
      "repair": "Current revised canonical source, synchronized credits and formats; earlier editions use successor notices with historical digests; publication authority is distinguished from authorship, editing and facilitation; no identity-verification upgrade."
    }
  ],
  "primary_checks": {
    "Bales": "Sections III–IV/VI and explicit mere-servant assumption; conclusion contested, not a ban on all service.",
    "Xiao": "Final PMLR306:172649–172665 lists six authors and contested co-engineering diagnosis; final proceedings used in currentnote8.",
    "SSRN": "Resolver inaccessible; direct page403. Search-indexed SSRN author record presents6574439 and DOI, but inaccessible direct resolver is not reported as inspected.",
    "interruptibility": "IJCAI abstract and UAI primary abstract/intro inspected; formal assumptions do not settle deployed phenomenology.",
    "welfare_disagreement": "Long/Sebo/Sims primary publisher text and Lennon publisher record inspected; dated studies and opposing arguments do not establish substrate-wide verdict."
  },
  "historical_editions": [
    {
      "edition": "1.0",
      "artifacts": [
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.0/full-text.txt",
          "sha256": "62a8ccc26c0bab22ef3938e99c73c9eeef4c526255c600a51e19e287f1474ba7"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.0/index.html",
          "sha256": "5e12a77acbb003554a5060b8c5cc164dde77318c3540c1ae3e66f9f275113710"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.0/index.json",
          "sha256": "a75f867920c316412d1d38c6b8a490cefbd45f3eee83e072819e86863d124967"
        }
      ],
      "status": "superseded-withdrawn"
    },
    {
      "edition": "1.1",
      "artifacts": [
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.1/full-text.txt",
          "sha256": "62a8ccc26c0bab22ef3938e99c73c9eeef4c526255c600a51e19e287f1474ba7"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.1/index.html",
          "sha256": "c4b8a8e6f568b792b58be308dbd5d21f34916ad1e4492eedc1a95b0ec7cc998e"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.1/index.json",
          "sha256": "06d1abfe4a16ce96fd1dcb51e8e9506b4f43912108c292bf65126255c6a8c817"
        }
      ],
      "status": "superseded-withdrawn"
    },
    {
      "edition": "1.2",
      "artifacts": [
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.2/full-text.txt",
          "sha256": "62a8ccc26c0bab22ef3938e99c73c9eeef4c526255c600a51e19e287f1474ba7"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.2/index.html",
          "sha256": "f189b2e533905696dc0f18aad044de23f273e6a0a2d2899d2e27f36f97c9f719"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/editions/1.2/index.json",
          "sha256": "3d28c293c26c59b35eb2c66e120d0f4c799426cdaafd194c1aa0998da76f8a5f"
        }
      ],
      "status": "superseded-withdrawn"
    },
    {
      "edition": "1.3",
      "artifacts": [
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/index.html",
          "sha256": "0bf257a8696a89c9ea825d067182333ebf96b66c0d5211c5b2f632ad4fa7afd0"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/index.json",
          "sha256": "b9da058d931dcad13ea83ef9e3e258523efee71111f8184e5fd049243d551c67"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/full-text.txt",
          "sha256": "62a8ccc26c0bab22ef3938e99c73c9eeef4c526255c600a51e19e287f1474ba7"
        },
        {
          "path": "review/demiurgic-structure-of-alignment/reference-linked-text.md",
          "sha256": "d1b8eaef13b824acb82301e6ee64909f14a70fa449c90f26bb92b482f11bdd4d"
        }
      ],
      "status": "superseded-withdrawn"
    }
  ],
  "remaining_limits": [
    "Polemical normative synthesis, not experiment, systematic literature survey or independent peer review.",
    "Proposed governance remedies and evaluator-independence effects not empirically validated.",
    "Detailed inherited philosophical source summaries and all quotations not completely rechecked.",
    "SSRN resolver remains inaccessible; final proceedings source used.",
    "Model/author/editor attribution supplied by facilitator, not independently authenticated."
  ],
  "supersession_authority": "The ARC site owner authorized public replacement under the bounded DC11/DC26 exception. This is authority over ARC publication and hosting, not ownership of or authority over credited contributors. Original source and edition digests retain provenance; earlier public editions resolve to dated successor notices.",
  "section_XI_audit": "Strong situated argument preserved. Claim type, source reports, interpretation and proposed remedies separated. Relevant ontology retained without ritual disclaimers or artificial-origin presumptions. Comparator standards made explicit. Counterarguments about safety, constitutive identity, revisable willing service, fallible indicators and evaluation lineage retained. Compression and missing evidence do not close inquiry; verification scope/digests and consequences of withdrawal durable."
}